I agree, I think its a mental issue pure and simple, no normal woman in their right mind would lie about something like being pregnant and/or miscarriage/stillbirth. Especially miscarriage or stillbirth. Also if they're lying to several people all the time about something like that its an obvious mental issue and cry for attention. They need couseling and possibly medication. Reminds me of those women that purposely make their babies ill for attention, so they look like good mothers, when in fact they're not.
clearly this happens alot, theres alot of pinnochios out there! i agree with the post above! "munchausen moms" !! is the term for mothers who harm their babies. i watched a documentary on it a couple of months ago and was distraught -why are these sick people allowed to live!!
i feel i need to put my 2 cents in here, while i agree it is wrong to lie about being pregnant and losing a child, as others in this thread have said the women who do this are obviously mentally ill.
i know it must be very painful to hear that someone has lied about having a miscarriage when some of us have actually had to go through the trauma of it, but the majority of these women who lie about being pregnant have to say they've had a miscarriage in most cases to end the lie, as once they've said it they may feel theres no way back and what other explanation could they give when theres really no baby?
to say that because they have lied about this they deserve to have a miscarriage if and when they do fall pregnant is an awful thing to say and it doesnt work like that. having had one myself i would never wish one on anyone.
obviously there is the odd exception when a woman may lie for attention or to keep a partner, but even this shows signs of someone who is very insecure and needs some sort of help.
my older sister couldnt have children and was so desperate to experience pregnancy that she lied to people about it and i think even tricked herself into believing she was. her explanation was that she wanted to know what it felt like to be considered worthy of being able to carry a child. she has now had professional help but i would never think bad of her as she was unwell.
mental illness is no different to physical and just because we arent always able to understand it we should not jump to conclusions about others and their reasons for their behaviour.
no one in a normal state of mind would behave like this and i feel these people need support instead of judgement
[/QUOTE]i know it must be very painful to hear that someone has lied about having a miscarriage when some of us have actually had to go through the trauma of it, but the majority of these women who lie about being pregnant have to say they've had a miscarriage in most cases to end the lie, as once they've said it they may feel theres no way back and what other explanation could they give when theres really no baby?[/QUOTE]
I think if someone is is going to lie about being pregnant, and then needs a way to end the lie they need to tell the truth and that it was a lie in the first place. Let's face it, I'm sure more people would respect them for coming out and saying it was a lie than if they LIED about having a miscarriage!
It makes me physically sick to my stomach to think ladies/girls say they've had a miscarriage, they have no idea!
I understand in some cases women are ill or whatever, for me though that's no excuse as harsh as it sounds.
i can understand what you are saying, i have been through a miscarriage myself and know how painful it is,but im sure very few people would understand if these women were honest and admitted they had lied. some may have more respect for them, including myself and u, but alot would just be disgusted and judgemental of just not understand. i know this was the case with my sister who did come clean.
by the way i am very sorry to hear of your loss
I guess I can understand that too, as much as I don't want too. The case with your sister it makes me feel sorry for her knowing she wanted to be pregnant so much she actually thought she were. And it's cases like that, that make me angry that 'normal' ladies can have babies but yet lie about it, to get attention or to stay in a relationship etc. They will experience pregnancy one day, but your sister won't. I can understand why your sister did it, and tbh I don't blame her, but ladies that just want attention etc just need a big kick!
Dykwim? I think I've worded it all wrong, Lol.
This seems to be pretty common judging from all the replies! My boyfriend was seeing a girl just before we got together (not a serious relationship) and kinda ditched her when he met me. She didn't take it very well and for the first month we were together she would be texting him all the time telling him she was pregnant etc. I never did find out if it was true or not, but I had huge suspicions she was lying - she ended up telling him she'd had a miscarriage too. I don't know for sure if she was lying but I think she was.
It's very very strange IMO - I guess I can understand people lying about it to their significant others, family members and friends, but what I can't understand is the women who come on here and similar forums to lie about being pregnant. That's just weird. I was wondering the other day why the rule is that you need to have your name and personal info on the scan pics that you post here, but now I get it! Very weird, obviously they have mental issues so you can't judge them too harshly, but it sure must be frustrating for everyone around them, so I would ignore them completely! xxx
A girl at my college in georgia was obsessed with pregnancy bc so many girls at our school were. When my best friend fell pregnant, she told us she was too. Mind you, we never saw a test. So we noticed her not getting any bigger, by now she should be about 14 weeks, we saw no sonogram pix and concluded she was doing it from envy for attention. At the end of the day, its a mental issue, or a pathological need to have something others have. I dont think she knows im pregnant, as we have stopped talking to her.
Any opinions, advice, statements or other information expressed or made available on BabyandBump.Momtastic.com by users or third parties, including but not limited to bloggers, are solely those of the respective user or other third party. They do not reflect the opinions of BabyandBump.Momtastic.com and they have not been reviewed by a physician, psychologist or parenting expert or any member of the BabyandBump.Momtastic.com staff for accuracy, balance or objectivity. Content and other information presented on BabyandBump.Momtastic.com are not a substitute for professional medical or mental health advice, counseling, diagnosis, or treatment. Never delay or disregard seeking professional medical or mental health advice from your physician or other qualified health provider because of something you have read on BabyandBump.Momtastic.com. BabyandBump.Momtastic.com does not endorse any opinion, advice, statement, product, service or treatment made available on the website. If you think you have a medical emergency, call your doctor or emergency services immediately.