A positive spin on tantrums

Marie000

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2012
Messages
1,359
Reaction score
0
I just read this article and found it really interesting, just thought I'd share with other mommies trying to cope with toddler tantrums. I'm not child development expert, but it seemed to make sense.

https://offbeatfamilies.com/2010/12/gift-of-tantrums
 
I love this and to me, it makes perfect sense!

Shoot- if it was socially acceptable I'd throw a "tantrum" just about daily myself! Due to: that stupid car taking up the fast lane... pushy people... mean people... financial stresses... taxes... my knee pain... shoulder pain... LIFE... there are plenty of reason for adults to be stressed, and we have self control! :haha:
 
I know what we should do! We need to start underground Tantrum Clubs for mommies.
 
I highly disagree. While I think crying is fine, and could be beneficial on many occasions, what I define to be tantrums: screaming, throwing, hitting etc are not desirable ways of channelling emotions and dealing with stress. Kids eventually grow up to be adults, so we teach them, gently and at a suitable pace, to act as responsible adults. It wouldn't be fair to let them tantrum as a child only to one day find out there are real world consequences for acting like that.

Of course, that is not to say we should ostracize kids or parents with kids who act out, dealing with emotions in a socially acceptable way is just something we need to teach our kids, like potty training.

To say that well behaved children are repressed is just plain wrong. There are experiments which show that children who have better self control perform better in life.

People (kids and adults) are allowed to be crabby when they are low or ill, then they get better and we expect them to act better, I don't see that as an excuse to say let's not try to correct the tantrums.
 
I love this article and it really does explain how I see tantrums or meltdowns.

My son had 2 1/2 yrs of terrible tantrums and meltdowns and never once did I try and stop him being angry. It wasn't easy to deal with in any way at all and often I would be in tears by the time he calmed down but he has a big temper and meltdowns were his way of dealing with the world around him not being as he wanted it to be. At 4 he no longer behaves like this very often and most of his anger has burnt out. He knows that if he is cross, he needs to go and chill out on his own and it's fine to be angry but not to hit, kick etc. if I had tried to suppress or control his temper and tantrums during that time I wonder if he would have outgrown them by now of whether he would still be having them because he hadn't learnt how to work through his anger and had the chance to let all the stress out.

On Monday he had a meltdown for the 1st time in ages. He was hungry and had had 3 hours playing solidly with a friend. He totally lost it washing his hands at the toilet in the supermarket. I got really dirty looks from a couple of people because instead of telling him off for screaming, I was hugging him while we were waiting for food in the cafe. But he was angry because he was hungry and overstimulated and needed to let it out. Once he'd had something to eat and a sit down he was fine. Telling him off or punishing him for being angry would have achieved nothing other than teach him it's not ok to feel out of control sometimes.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,317
Messages
27,145,842
Members
255,769
Latest member
joewp
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"
<-- Admiral -->