Question for those who experienced both Csection and Vaginal Births...

Clever.Name

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
350
Reaction score
0
...I had an emergency Csection with my first, and I'm really torn on what to do for this baby. Originally I was set on having an elective csection, (I have one booked) as I had a really easy, fast, painless recovery from the first one. I've always been terrified of a vaginal birth and have no big burning desires to have one. In fact, i'm more nervous about natural delivery than a csection. How things might never be the same "down there" afterwards? The stretching? the healing?
But recently I've been thinking that maybe I should give a VBAC a try.
Thoughts from those who had both? How was your healing after the VBAC? are you glad you did it?
I'm mostly just worried my labour will end up in another emergency csection and don't really want to go through that again.
Thanks!
 
I had an emergency section 1st time around, then a Vbac. I had no burning desire to give birth naturally etc, just decided on vbac as thats what the consultant said carried less risk, and thought the recovery would be easier. I'm so glad I did it. I got a 3rd degree tear which wasn't ideal, but did it all with no pain relief at all, and the healing was fine. (6 weeks later I wouldn't have known anything was different). I think if I had a section again , the healing would have been worse. Giving birth was amazing, and like I said, I wasn't the kind of woman who felt I needed to give birth naturally etc. I would probably have asked for an epidural etc, but turned up to hospital fully dilated so didn't have time. It was an amazing experience and I'm so happy that I got to experience it.
 
My first was a section after long labour and pushing for ages, i dont know if that contributed to my recovery but it took ages to recover and i was always worried about the scar. I didnt relax until a good 2 years later!
My 2nd a vbac, with epidural and forceps, better recovery even with an episotomy felt normal after a week
3rd again a vbac fast labour few tears but felt unbelievable a few houra after labour even nurses were commenting on how i didnt look like i'd just given birth! However at home recovery from stitches down there took ages, couldnt sit or relax and i felt it was same as my c section recovery at first.
4th was another vbac which was supposed to be an elective c section, but labour started and again so fast within 3 hrs from first sign! More tears and a good few weeks to fully recover.
This time probably another vbac and expecting more tears but i know i'll feel nirmal within weeks instead of the months it took with section, however knowing my luck i'll probably end up with an emergency section!
My main reason for vbac is so i can get back to normal with the kids within a short time.
It depends on your own body some people recover from sections a lot better, from my experience i didnt have a good recovery and i think it was more to do with feeling totally nbirmal for me, that i got with te vbacs.
 
My first was an emergency c section and recovery was a good six weeks. Seven weeks ago I had a vbac and felt amazing after. I had a second degree year that I barely could feel. I was exercising at 2 weeks pp and was able to care for my toddler with no problems . I actually didn't even feel like I have birth after, it was unreal compared to a csection. Hoping you do what is right for you :)
 
I've had 2 vaginal births and then a c section third time.
But never had another after the section, so no vbac here.

For me even though my vaginal births were extremely long, they were easier births and I recovered better and a lot quicker from them than I did section.

However when we had another I would opt a repeat section as I don't want to take the risks of a vbac and esp going by what my previous vaginal births were like.

go with what is right for you.
 
Your vagina will be fine lol- Trust me! I have done 3 vaginal births and then later had 3 c sections. honestly the recovery for vag was a lot quicker, was able to move around way faster and quicker, and resumed sex before 6 wks. With my c sections there was a longer recovery a tad more painful with cramping - first one hurt like hell- the next one hurt but not as bad the third one hurt but not as bad either. Those last 2 - I would say 2 wks down. my first took me about 3-4 wks. but vaginal birth- like 3-4 days I was good. I'd rather a Vaginal- Im actually doing a vbac too , VBA3C. Good Luck to you!!!!! :)
 
thanks to all! It's funny, when I first got preg, I insisted i'd have another csection, that's why we booked it. Now that I'm getting closer to due date, I'm starting to think I would like to just go with the flow and see what happens. I'm mostly just scared of my girlfriends' stories of "peeing when sneezing" and things not being the same afterwards. Since I had such an easy recovery from 1st csection, I thought, well why not? it's the "known" way....but now i'm thinking might wanna try.
I really don't know what's right for me, that's the trouble! Guess i'll have to decide soon.......thanks, your stories are helpful!
 
I had a vaginal birth with my first, and a c-section (planned - he was breech) for my second. The c-section was very calm and much less traumatic, but hands down the vaginal birth was an easier recovery! I was sore for a few days but nothing like the soreness after the section. My vagina was just fine and I had no trouble with my pelvic floor (takes a little while to feel the muscles
properly again though!)I had an episiotomy which took around a week to stop stinging but it wasn't so bad. I also had some ugly hemorrhoids but they went away. I was walking around town pushing my baby in his pram just days after he was born.
 
...I had an emergency Csection with my first, and I'm really torn on what to do for this baby. Originally I was set on having an elective csection, (I have one booked) as I had a really easy, fast, painless recovery from the first one. I've always been terrified of a vaginal birth and have no big burning desires to have one. In fact, i'm more nervous about natural delivery than a csection. How things might never be the same "down there" afterwards? The stretching? the healing?
But recently I've been thinking that maybe I should give a VBAC a try.
Thoughts from those who had both? How was your healing after the VBAC? are you glad you did it?
I'm mostly just worried my labour will end up in another emergency csection and don't really want to go through that again.
Thanks!

I could have written this myself. Intact I was going to until I stumbled across this post so I wanted to give it a little bump to see if we could get a few more answers.
 
...I had an emergency Csection with my first, and I'm really torn on what to do for this baby. Originally I was set on having an elective csection, (I have one booked) as I had a really easy, fast, painless recovery from the first one. I've always been terrified of a vaginal birth and have no big burning desires to have one. In fact, i'm more nervous about natural delivery than a csection. How things might never be the same "down there" afterwards? The stretching? the healing?
But recently I've been thinking that maybe I should give a VBAC a try.
Thoughts from those who had both? How was your healing after the VBAC? are you glad you did it?
I'm mostly just worried my labour will end up in another emergency csection and don't really want to go through that again.
Thanks!

I could have written this myself. Intact I was going to until I stumbled across this post so I wanted to give it a little bump to see if we could get a few more answers.

Thanks Maybe1daysoon!! Let's hope so!! I'm still on the fence!
 
I could have written this myself. Intact I was going to until I stumbled across this post so I wanted to give it a little bump to see if we could get a few more answers.[/QUOTE]

Do you know the reason you had to have an EMCS? I'm finding part of my frustration/confusion is not really understanding why my labour ended up the way it did. If there is something physiologically about me that does not allow for a regular birth, then I am happy to go with the csection. I just want to know. My son got stuck and his hr was dropping and that's why we ended up in EMCS. I just wish they could tell me one way or the other so it could help my decision process, you know?
My OB says he doesn't want to sway my decision however has told me several times that if my labour didn't progress last time, there is a high chance the same thing could happen again..........hmf. SO hard to know what to do.
 
My c section was because of a failed induction. After 4 days and trying everything under the sun, we finally delivered via csection. I was induced because of gestational diabetes and I don't think my body was ready so no matter what they did I wouldn't labor. I want to give my body a chance to ACTUALLY go into active labor. However, if I get gd again I'm sure they will want to do a repeat. It's ultimately my choice but I wanted to know pain wise which was easiest (before, during, and after).
 
I could have written this myself. Intact I was going to until I stumbled across this post so I wanted to give it a little bump to see if we could get a few more answers.

Do you know the reason you had to have an EMCS? I'm finding part of my frustration/confusion is not really understanding why my labour ended up the way it did. If there is something physiologically about me that does not allow for a regular birth, then I am happy to go with the csection. I just want to know. My son got stuck and his hr was dropping and that's why we ended up in EMCS. I just wish they could tell me one way or the other so it could help my decision process, you know?
My OB says he doesn't want to sway my decision however has told me several times that if my labour didn't progress last time, there is a high chance the same thing could happen again..........hmf. SO hard to know what to do.[/QUOTE]

One thing I'd recommend is thinking about why things didn't progress (and even what 'not progressing' means). Some women are more nervous in a hospital environment, with bright lights, strangers coming and going, being interrupted all the time, which can cause the body to slow up labour (it's basically our body's instinctual way of protecting our babies from being born into danger, if we feel stressed or like we don't have enough quiet or privacy, labour will slow until we feel comfortable again). You might be someone who needs to stay at home longer so you can labour in somewhere quiet and familiar, or you might think of using a birth center that's more home-like and less like a hospital. Being on your back rather than upright (on a birth ball, on hands and knees, walking around) can slow things, as can not eating or drinking regularly, or having too many well-meaning but distracting friends and family in the room with you. Going into labour spontaneously (not induced), being somewhere relaxing, quiet and private, being upright and walking around, and eating/drinking regularly will help keep things moving.

Also, sometimes labour just slows down. That's fine. There's nothing wrong with it and it's no risk to baby at all, except that in our modern era of continuous monitoring, we are more likely to pick up on little changes in heart rate that aren't clinically significant at all. There's actually been some interesting research that shows that since we started to do continuous fetal monitoring (that's being hooked up to the monitor that goes around your belly), it's not actually made birth safer but has led to more interventions, some of them unnecessary. If you were being monitored a lot, a small variation in HR could have been picked up, but it may not have meant anything. They picked one up during my birth (just once), but my daughter was fine. I laboured another 4 hours (4 hours of pushing, I might add) before she was born. We were both perfectly healthy. I think in a different situation, with midwives who weren't as experienced, they would have gotten more nervous that it was taking so long (I'm sure some OBs would say that a 4 hour 2nd stage is 'non-progression' and probably would have pushed a c-section or wanted to use forceps). But it wasn't needed. We were fine and comfortable. We just needed time. So it could have been you would have been just fine if you'd been given more time to just get on with it. It's impossible to know now, but I'd try to think of things you can do differently this time (like staying at home longer, being more upright, keeping your energy levels up). Your body really can do it, but sometimes the modern birthing environment isn't conducive to just getting out of your body's way and letting you do what you need to do. So push for the little things you need, like being able to walk around or eat what you want or use a birth pool or shower or a birth ball, etc.
 
Wow thanks so much MindUtopia. To be honest, I was actually quite relaxed for most of it, labouring on my own (without an epidural) for hours, I was doing some hypnobirthing, bouncing on a ball, walking around, etc. I unfortunately had to come straight to the hospital after my water broke because I was GBS positive, and those were the rules for my hospital, I had to be put right on the drip. Then as things weren't progressing on their own, they wanted to give me Oxytocin, we eventually agreed. If I could do it again, I wouldn't change anything except to refuse the oxytocin and let myself labour as long as possible to see if things would progress naturally. I really think the oxy sped things up so much that my body just wasn't ready for it, neither was the baby.
I don't know yet whether I have GBS again, but I'm at a different hospital and they have different rules, my OB said they wouldn't necessarily give me the Oxy right away, only the antibiotics drip.
I'm actually leaning more towards trying to let labour happen naturally, mostly because I've found out that I'm having another small baby (my son was only 5.10 at birth) and I don't want to have a csection at 38 weeks if I can help it as that means baby will be small again. That's the only time they will elective csection me though, no later.
I figure even if I labour again, and end up in csection again, at least I tried, and I will have let my baby bake as long as she needs to, to try to fatten up!!
I don't know - so confusing!!!! Thanks all for the support you guys are great xo
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,317
Messages
27,145,886
Members
255,771
Latest member
leanne10
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"
<-- Admiral -->