what is the point of a christening if you're not religious?

We will be getting this baby baptised as we did with dd and ds, we are both Catholic and go to Mass every week.

My priest must be very strict as there is no way you would be allowed to baptise if you didn't regularly attend Mass and go to the course you have to do which instructs you how the Catholic Church expect you to raise your child in the faith.

He also won't sign forms of any non-Catholics/lapsed Catholics to agree to let them in the primary schools either. Makes me laugh because before we had this priest and the school were less strict I had one Mum complaining in the playground as the children had to say prayers several times a day and she didn't agree with it!! Duh hello it's a Catholic School!! :dohh:

Maybe she is in an area like mine where there only is catholic schools *or where I am miles away you have the odd protestant one*. One school accepted my son who is not christened. Rest said no and some where rude. But he will be left out of RE class and assembly. School board says this is down to the schools discretion. Not sure how that works yet and I am told already no one will supervise him so he maybe forced in to religion classes. but I wont christen my children because every one else does so they can fit their child in with the schools, they have a mixed family anyway from both sides of the fence in NI as we call it. We dont have any minorities here in my area, My son will be the first to be left out of RE in the school and I have been called bad mum several times for making him this way. I wish we had some choice here it feels very discriminative. Many just home school their kids if this happens sadly I cant do that at the moment.

No, there are loads of schools in the area. It's known as nappy valley here locally. It just so happens the school had the best ofstead reports, nice small classes, village feel and so was very desirable. It was just funny how she thought it was so odd and didn't agree that the school was so religious, even though it is a Catholic school meant for Catholic children to raise your kids in the faith so if she wasn't religious at all or agree with the amount of religion taught/expressed then maybe a different school would have been better choice for her :)

ETA: I am shocked that you have been spoken to rudely and made to feel like a bad mum for leaving your boy out of RE. That should be your prerogative especially since you don't have much choice on where he goes to school. I'm sorry you've been made to feel that way, and hope your son gets on well, I'm sure he will.

I get it now, she choose the educational side over religion yet weirdly complained about it and she had a choice. She dosnt know how lucky she is to have that choice. You are expected to convert here in most schools. We are well behind here in times. I do know they are fighting for educated together schools as they have in the south or Ireland. I just dont want to follow the herd and christen my sons because every one does to get them in to a school and be atheist and never practise religion at home. It dosnt seem right at all. I have nothing against any one that does I was raised catholic.
 
I was thinking of having a naming ceremony 'christening' for both my babies but i changed my mind... didnt see the point in wasting money if im honest but it wouldnt matter if i raised them catholic or not, theyre are both going to be going to a catholic school, simply because its a very good school, not because of its religion xx
 
I was thinking of having a naming ceremony 'christening' for both my babies but i changed my mind... didnt see the point in wasting money if im honest but it wouldnt matter if i raised them catholic or not, theyre are both going to be going to a catholic school, simply because its a very good school, not because of its religion xx

Though they cant make holy communion or confirmation if not christened.
 
We are not religious and not had dd christened.
I have just spent 6 weeks arguing with the school board why I don't want my dd going to a catholic school in Sept there are 6 other schools she could go to and it wasn't even my closest school. She's got into a different school now I don't see why they placed her there in the first place

Back to why I came to post
Speaking to my friend yesterday who doesn't attend church had her kids christened asked why ....the presents seriously thebminey spent on it she could of got them herself
 
I don't see the point of "naming ceremonies" at all.

Either christen the baby into your faith or don't. No one (in my opinion) needs a ceremony to name them when you've already decided a name.

If people want a party then fine, but I don't understand the whole naming ceremony thing.
 
I'm glad I read this thread as I am having issues with this currently!
DH and I are not religious we were both christened. My mum told me my sister and i were only christened as she was pressured into it by my dads parents. I personally don't want to get LO christened as I think it hypocritical when both myself and DH are not religious.

I am getting pressure from MIL and DH to have LO christened and when I say no MIL looks at me as if I have two heads! MIL is not particularly religious in the time I have been with DH she has not once attended church etc.
I agree that on the most part a christening (to some people not all) is an excuse for a party and piss up. Prime example...DH's trainee is having his daughter christened soon and is annoyed that he is unable to have the following day off of work as he will be hungover! It shouldn't be about getting drunk!!
 
Im not religious but my LO is christened. Mainly due to pressure from family who think it's 'tradition'. My family were saying did I not want her to have god's blessing, and my husband's family were saying that it was traditional and we should have a christening. It just seemed easier :| My mil used it as an excuse to get drunk and could hardly walk when she got home... :(
 
My lo is christened. We are both Catholic and it was very important to us that we did so.

Where we're from what priests allow differs from parish to parish. My parish is here in town where the priest only allows christening's on a Sunday, you must have a meeting in your own home with the "christening committee" and only mum can hold baby during the christening ceremony he will also refuse to christen your baby unless at least one member of you family is in regular attendance at our church.
My Dh's parish which is only 10 mins drive out the country does things differently. The priest there will do christening's on a Saturday, you will meet the christening committee in the parochial house and dad can hold baby during christening.

We choose to have it in Dh's parish for a few different reasons one being we could have it on a Saturday as it wasn't feasible for us to ask family members who live very far away to drive up and down on the same day to be back for work Monday morning.

We also disagreed with some of the members of the christening committee here coming to our house. One of them is known for being quite extreme in her religious views and we don't like that.

My lo will being going to a catholic primary and secondary school not because the schools are very religion orientated but because they are the best schools in our area.
 
It's pretty pointless period seeing as no matter what you promise or dedicated to them, they will end up making their own decision in life. It's especially pointless and wrong if you're not religious because your promising you'll raise your child is said religion, which is lying to everyone if you don't plan on doing that. Doing it just because family insists is the wrong reason to do it. What would "you" rather do? It isn't about everyone else.
 
I was christened when I was 7, my mum asked me if I wanted to be and I really wish she hadn't! I didn't really understand what I was agreeing to and I think it's completely pointless if you don't believe in it all. My son hasn't been christened and I don't plan on changing that. x
 
hubby and I are atheists so my baby won't be christened. However, I don't find it disrespectful to be christened in a church if you're not really planing on attending church services. Ppl do it because of pressure from family and similar reasoning.

It's like u got a gym membership but u don't go often or ever. How is that offensive?
 
hubby and I are atheists so my baby won't be christened. However, I don't find it disrespectful to be christened in a church if you're not really planing on attending church services. Ppl do it because of pressure from family and similar reasoning.

It's like u got a gym membership but u don't go often or ever. How is that offensive?

Personally, I find it more offensive to the ministers. Surely to them, it is a commitment to God and your church, and it must be kinda hard to do it if you know they have no intention to return; they could even simply be doing it for the party aspect or to be sanctimonious.

It's a shame that people are pressured into it by their own families as I wholly believe in choice of baptism. I do sympathise, as both sides of my family are devout catholic and I've had a level of familial discrimination for my non Catholic (but still very Christian) upbringing by my mum who renounced herself from the Catholic Church.
 
I don't believe in it if you aren't religious. I am agnostic and my OH is non-practicing Catholic so we don't.
 
heh, one of my friends is getting her son christened and I was surprised as I had no idea she was religious and her reply to me asking her about it was "any excuse for a party!!!"

I wont be getting either of my girls christened. They will be brought up atheists.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,430
Messages
27,150,602
Members
255,846
Latest member
monikabavuro
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"