i hope you dont mind me responding, answering as a teen not a parent
Iv always been brought up to be respectful, and tbh when i did do things wrong i was only ever being punished for doing whatever i did - that entailed being grounded, having my stuff taken away etc.
It sounds to me like she needs her attitude sorting, rather than individual cases of wrong doing iykwim? I had friends like this, with lovely parents they insist on being horrible to. It wound me up something rotten, and i felt for their parents. Taking stuff away was always there first trick as well. Kinda if you are gonna do things to make me unhappy im gonna do stuff to make u unhappy - well thats how it comes across.
Unfortunatly from everything iv seen that just introduces a tit-for-tat kinda relationship...always trying to get one over on the other. It makes the teen feel like they have to 'win'
Have you tried talking to her? Asking her why she cant understand the concept of respect and explaining that its not fun for you to take her stuff away. Im sure in your ideal world everyone in your household would be able to do the things they want to and be happy - its not fun for you to have to punish, u gain nothing from it.
Manners and respect arent about someone being subservient to someone else - they are about wanting others to be comfortable in your company/
Try explaining she would deserve respect herself if she could learn the concept of it to others.
Sorry if youve already tried all that, im here if you ever want the teens perspective.
Big
tho, it cant be fun dealing with a bag or hormones that doesnt know how to control them yet
Dw, one day shell grow up and both of you will laugh at these arguments
xxxxx