I do have personal experience!!!!
OH from the beginning didn't want to use disposables. I was like "Hells NO!" when it came to cloth diapers. I did not want ANYTHING to do with poop. So with some research, OH comes up with the gDiapers. Seems fanatastic, right?
We even stocked up on them. Every week we'd go and buy a few more. Of course being our first we were totally naive about the cost of diapers. So Claire comes along. We stuck to disposables until her cord fell off, then switched to the gdiapers.
The Pros?
They are as easy as they look. Literally, you rip off the side, do a "swish swish" with the little stick thing in the starter packs and you are good to go. They're also super cute. The little "g" on the bum was to die for (in my books, at least!)
The Cons:
Washing poop off a plastic insert was disgusting. No idea why my tolerance to it was so low. But yeah, gross. The nighttime "sushi roll" was annoying as well. At that point, we were changing her "night" diapers 3 times, so that meant 2 inserts every time we changed her to prevent leaks. Yikes.
So yeah, it was cost that drove us to other solutions. At first, I was like "Heck yeah, I'll pay more to save the environment!!!"
but in reality, the cost is absurd. I was paying $20 for a package of 40 liners. Again, not having experience with these sorts of things I thought I was getting a deal.
Then I was at Shopper's Drug Mart (yeah, all these prices are CDN $$) and I saw a package of Pampers... it cost $23 for a package of 84 diapers.
That's when I blew a gasket. With that stupid "sushi roll" thing, we were going through a package of liners every 2-3 days... which meant around $40 a week for diapers. That's nuts! Especially when a package of disposables would last 2.5 weeks for half the price.
At that point, I told OH that I wanted to protect the environment, but not at the expense of my bank account. We went back to disposables for awhile. Then I started feeling bad about the disposables so I looked into the cloth diapers that a friend was using. She got the BumGenius ones, and they were totally cute! I warmed up to them and now that's what we use.
I bought a few Fuzzi Bunz for good measure, but I still like the BG's more. If you have any more questions, please feel free to ask me. The gdiapers were a great idea, but insanely expensive. When buying cloth the diapers "pay" for themselves after awhile.
We bought 24 to start, which ran about $580. However, given the cost of disposables, after 6 months of use they pay for themselves. BG are BTP (Birth to Potty) so you do get your money's worth and more. Anyways, I would research cloth diapers before you throw away loads of money using the gdiapers.
Sorry for the novel!