I'm not pregnant but I've been thinking about this a lot lately for when/if we ttc for number two.
I had an emcs due to non progressive labour, they then told me that I would never have gotten her out as she was back to back and a big baby, I asked my hv after I was home if I would have scans to try and determine size but they said no. I'd be tested for diabetes and that's it (I know growth scans can be unpredictable).
For me, I'd love a vbac as I'd love immediate skin to skin and that feeling of pushing baby out. I think the emotional part of baby being here that I thought I'd have was taken away because she was delivered by a section. It just wasn't what I'd envisioned.
Now though, I think I'd opt for elective section and ask for the things that I feel I missed, like immediate skin to skin that wasn't possible with the emcs. I'm so worried that my labour would be like the last which was long and resulted in them pushing for me to go natural (I got to 9cm and they left me for hours to see if anything would happen), by the end I was so tired I was pretty much out cold.
I say weigh up both options in depth, only you know the right decision for you.
X