Me and Oh had the same problemwe just had totally different opinions on girls names! We only agreed on one, Evie Kate on the way to hospital! We had a boy though (Angas). My plan was though to keep my favourite girls name to myself until 'she' was born and then i was going to suggest it and hopefully oh would be more obliging!
My taste in girls names seems similar to yours, I loved Anabel but oh flat out said no.
What about names like Summer, Lottie, Alice, Eden, Faith, Adeline (Addy).