Torn between two names!

[BethHx]

Really struggling! One day I love Phoebe the next I love Eliza. We've asked family and they all love both names. Many of my friends dislike Eliza which does put me off slightly as I want to get good reactions when I say my babies name. So ...

Phoebe Eliza Lily S.
Or
Eliza May Lily S.

All names are family names so not worried about popularity etc. which do you prefer?c

 

[Mummy2Corban]

Eliza may xx

 

[emyandpotato]

Eliza May, but Eliza Phoebe Lily is lovely!

 

[5_Year_Plan]

I like phoebe Eliza Lilly as I'm not a fan of May as a middle name as lots of people just use it as a filler/extension for no reason. I know it's a family name for you & I like using family names & phoebe & Eliza are both beautiful, so either would be great! But if I had to choose that would be my vhoice
Xxx

 

[MUMOF5]

Obvs you know I LOVE Phoebe, I think Phoebe Eliza Lily sounds just beautiful. x

 

[lovelylaura]

I like phoebe more. But try calling her that for a week or so and see how you feel then. I always feel different about a name once its being said out loud.

 

[Nanninoo]

I like both names! I've always liked phoebe but Eliza is cute x

 

[CloverMouse]

Eliza was on our list, but I think I prefer Phoebe, dh hates it though

 

[bananabump]

Eliza May is beautiful x

 

[daneuse27]

Personally not a huge fan of the name Phoebe - reminds me of the Friends character lol. Its an ok name though, I just prefer Eliza.

 

[Scarlett_paws]

I like Eliza may more I think is sounds cute.
This shocks me as phoebe was my girls name choice so I would have thought I would have liked that more

 

[JJKCB]

Eliza Mae

 

[mazndave]

I love Eliza, it's on my list but DH doesn't like it x

 

[vickyandchick]

I think Eliza is lovely

 

[BethHx]

Thankyou you're due the day after me. Are you staying team yellow?xxx

 

[Buttercup84]

I really like both and they both go well with your dd's name but i'm leaning towards Eliza

 

[JJKCB]

ignore this it posted to the wrong thread lol

 

[sue2012]

I love Eliza may x

 

[MrsButterfly]

Eliza would be my favourite I think.