Oh, that's terrible Britt. Poor guy. I hope he's doing better now. They're finding now that simply applying a steroid cream to the foreskin helps successfully treat conditions like that. Most boys his age aren't supposed to be retractable, so I can see where your doctor said he went "too far". Gosh, I can't imagine what he went through, but understandable why you'd choose circumcision this time.
My first son didn't have any complications with his, but my youngest son developed buried penis, and 7 months after the circumcision, he was hospitalized for severe meatal stenosis, where scar tissue grows over the urinary opening. He literally couldn't urinate. It was painful for him and he couldn't completely empty his bladder. The pressure from a constantly full bladder put pressure on his bowels so he couldn't have a bowel movement, and the constipation put pressure on his stomach, and he wouldn't eat. He ended up losing weight in just a months time and was finally admitted to the hospital for a week on IV antibiotics when they found he had a penile infection, kidney infection, kidney damage...VCUGs and ultrasounds revealed he also has duplex kidney (3 kidneys) that had put him at a higher risk for kidney damage. He had to go through blood tests every day, and they could only thread a 24-week preemie catheter through the urinary opening. He was 7 months old.
Once the infections cleared, they released him but he has to be followed by urology and nephrology for his kidneys and to watch for this complication to flare again. He will have to have surgery to correct the stenosis. They didn't do it during the hospital stay because they were afraid that they would open him too much, and then he'd require a third surgery to close it again, so they're waiting until he's 3 unless he has more health complications.
With Chase's case, though, he has no medical need to be circumcised and with no one listening to Chase, bring torn from his mother, having this forced on him, his mother being coerced into consenting by being threatened with jailtime...it's a heartbreaking circus.