I've had both. One natural no epidural one induced with epidural, both vaginal.
To me, the most brutal was the one where I was induced and my waters were broken. Epidural worked until push time and then it only half worked. I could barely tell I was pushing and afterwards I wasn't allowed to walk for a few hours so I was catheterized to pee.
Wth my second I was petrified of a similar painful experience. I went to the hospital at 37 weeks with labor pains. After a quiet night, they sent me home at 805am. On my way home the contractions picked back up. I still went home, labored there waiting for my contractions to get to the "normal" 2-3 minutes apart that would indicate "it's time". My contractions were severe but I was petrified they would even get worse as they were only 7-8minutes apart . I kept expecting the intensity to rise like my first- my waters hadn't even broken yet! After getting in a hot shower until it ran cold and doing a lot of moaning and swaying outside the shower my contractions still weren't closer but the pain was real. I was in my own world, but it was manageable with intense concentration.
Finally I told my husband to take me to the hospital where I was checked and determined to be dilated to 6cm (I left at 3cm hours earlier)
While waiting for my anesthesiologist I was in severe pain but kept expecting it all to get worse. When he finally showed up My OB was right behind him and she wouldn't allow the epidural until she had checked me. When she did my contractions were still at 7-8 minutes apart, my
Waters had not broken and I was 10cm dilated and 100% effaced.
Discharged earlier that morning at 805am and after pushing for 20 minutes she was born at 1145am.
My waters never broke on there own. My contractions never got closer together. My recovery was incredible and once I had her it literally was all over. I took a shower, I breast fed, I felt incredible- though exhausted beyond belief.
After two experiences I would pick natural ANY day of the week. I realize now the worst of it was expecting for it to get worse.
Be prepared for "the ring of fire"....but rest easy knowing that once the burn comes you are literally seconds from it all being over....