Hi,
I have had two natural births. Both fine, but I would say the vagina does stretch, and is bigger for a while, but as long as you do the pelvic floor exercises afterwards it does go back to normal eventually. To be honest though this was the last thing on my mind after having the baby. I really couldnt have cared less about my vagina, I was so busy with the baby. I think it is one of those things you worry about before the event.
Now I am pregnant again, and I am starting to worry about all the problems with my body, but at the end of the day I know all of that wont really matter, I will be having another natural birth all being well.
You have to do what you believe is best for you and your baby.
My personal opinion is that a natural birth if possible is the most wonderful way of bringing a child into the world.
x