Peditrician told me I could start my child on level1 baby food at 4 months

Jazzycat123

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
164
Reaction score
0
I do formula with him because of issues that prevented me from BF after 3 months. He went for his 4 month eval and shots. The doctor told me I could start him on some level 1 baby foods. But the American Association of Pediatrics guidelines say not until 6 months as a sole source of nutrition. I had a mother literally jump down my throat today when i said I might start him on one food. I am not sure what to do now. When did everyoen start their children on foods and would I be doing my child any harm by starting him slowly on other foods?
 
Evelyn's pediatrician also said 4 months, and she showed all of the signs of being ready for solids. I started her on rice cereal, which she hated, so I chucked it and switched to Earth's Best Organic Stage 1 baby jars. She has been in heaven since then! :haha:

Here are the guidelines from the AAP, which actually say 4-6 months, depending on when the baby is showing signs of being ready:

https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/baby/feeding-nutrition/Pages/Switching-to-Solid-Foods.aspx

In the end it's going to be what you're comfortable with as their parent. If you want to wait until 6 months, then that is perfectly fine! If you want to try out solids after 4 months if you think your baby is ready, then that is fine too. :hugs:
 
I waited because there is no way of knowing for sure if babies guts are ready for it before 6 months. 'They' know the gut matures between 4-6 months so that's why most pediatricians will tell you its your choice to start now or wait til 6 months. If you believe your LO is ready then go for it. Don't let anyone make you feel like crap for your decisions. If 'they' were definite that babies aren't ready at 4 or 5 months the option to start then wouldn't be available.

I have no idea who 'they' are I think its the same people you mentioned. I just remember reading a TON of stuff about it because everyone kept saying NO FOODS BEFORE 6 MONTHS...
 
Even at 6 months solids shouldn't be the sole source of their nutrition! With that being said, starting at 4 months is perfectly acceptable. Everyone has a different opinion on which age is best to start but in the end it's best to go with what your baby's telling you. I was given the go ahead to start dd1 at 5 months as her pediatrician felt it was the right time to start the weaning process. She took to it well. Dd2 I started at 6 months as she showed no signs of being ready earlier. She wasn't ready at 6 months either but I kept trying and by 7ish months she started to eat more.
 
Based on my personal research on this, the biggest reasons for waiting to start solids only apply if you're breastfeeding. You said that you're doing formula, so, there you go. You need to look for signs your baby is ready beyond just "oh, four months old" (hopefully your pediatrician did this), though.

You start with very small amounts at a time- at most a teaspoon of solids once a day- and slowly work up.

If you don't feel comfortable doing so- don't. Do your own research, trust your gut, talk to your partner if you have one. You know your baby best.

My baby would NOT eat solids until over a week after turning 6 months despite offering them from 4 months- just wasn't ready. Some babies will grab food off their parents' plates at four months and are even ready for baby led weaning (this is a really good method if you're worried about your baby being ready or not).
 
Personally I don't understand wanting to start early as solids are a lot of hassle! It was so much easier when I only had to prepare feeds throughout the day. I was happy to wait until nearly six months as milk is so much easier!
 
Personally I don't understand wanting to start early as solids are a lot of hassle! It was so much easier when I only had to prepare feeds throughout the day. I was happy to wait until nearly six months as milk is so much easier!

I personally don't believe in not doing something for my child just because it isn't easy. But to each their own! :)
 
Personally I don't understand wanting to start early as solids are a lot of hassle! It was so much easier when I only had to prepare feeds throughout the day. I was happy to wait until nearly six months as milk is so much easier!

I personally don't believe in not doing something for my child just because it isn't easy. But to each their own! :)

It's true - solids *are* a lot of work. Take a trip out, for example: previously it was prepare enough bottles and formula for LO; now it is prepare bottles and formula, plus snacks. Will we be out for lunch? Where are we going? LO is BLW but there is still salt content to consider so I prepare a back up lunch in case what we have isn't suitable. Oh and let's not forget the packets of wipes to clean surfaces and unhygienic highchairs... Plus food often gets on the floor and LO needs cleaning afterwards. I have no idea how it would work if purées were involved - maybe some defrosting and heating? I dunno! Whereas with milk it was simply mix formula, feed baby and burp! My thoughts are simply that a lot of parents are in a rush to wean as it's new and exciting (I couldn't wait and it was tough to get to nearly six months) but it comes with its own set of hassles.

On the plus side, now LO is weaned going out for lunch is loads of fun as he loves sitting at the table and eating with us. We get to eat (share) our lunch with a happy (greedy) baby and there's no fussing because he's bored!
 
One of mine was on formula from 3.5 months too but I didn't start him on solids until he was over 6 months for various reasons. One, the very reason I started him on formula to begin with was due to food intolerance and digestive troubles I didn't want to set things back by inadvertently starting solids too early. Two he wasn't interested. Three I wanted to do BLW from the start although we didn't end up being able to do BLW. Four the UK government advise waiting until as close to six months as possible regardless of breastfed or formula fed. Xx
 
Personally I don't understand wanting to start early as solids are a lot of hassle! It was so much easier when I only had to prepare feeds throughout the day. I was happy to wait until nearly six months as milk is so much easier!

I personally don't believe in not doing something for my child just because it isn't easy. But to each their own! :)

It's true - solids *are* a lot of work. Take a trip out, for example: previously it was prepare enough bottles and formula for LO; now it is prepare bottles and formula, plus snacks. Will we be out for lunch? Where are we going? LO is BLW but there is still salt content to consider so I prepare a back up lunch in case what we have isn't suitable. Oh and let's not forget the packets of wipes to clean surfaces and unhygienic highchairs... Plus food often gets on the floor and LO needs cleaning afterwards. I have no idea how it would work if purées were involved - maybe some defrosting and heating? I dunno! Whereas with milk it was simply mix formula, feed baby and burp! My thoughts are simply that a lot of parents are in a rush to wean as it's new and exciting (I couldn't wait and it was tough to get to nearly six months) but it comes with its own set of hassles.

On the plus side, now LO is weaned going out for lunch is loads of fun as he loves sitting at the table and eating with us. We get to eat (share) our lunch with a happy (greedy) baby and there's no fussing because he's bored!

Kiddo will eat both finger foods and puree cool when we're out. (as adults, we eat our fruits and veg cold quite often- if you're baby's willing, no reason not to) We're college students so 2-3 of our meals are out of home most days, and our college rarely has baby-safe foods (once in a blue moon). So:

-Container with teething biscuits
-Jar of storebought puree
-Container with fruit/veg finger food
-Container with home made puree
-Spoons. So many spoons.

(the storebought puree can be left at room temp unless open. The last two should go in a cooler of some sort. Everything except the spoons is optional, it's a mix and match of what we have ready and available.)

Those are four small containers, sometimes in a cooler- which you often need when dealing with bottles anyways- sometimes not. The wipes you need to deal with cleaning up after diaper changes or after going potty if you're doing EC anyways and, frankly, are a good idea with a baby. Unless your baby is a positively meticulous bottle feeder, you need to wipe milk off their faces either way.

I really don't find it any more difficult, especially with eating out. Thanks to BLW it's actually WAY easier. Now, instead of having to take turns on which adult gets to eat while the other holds and entertains the baby, kiddo gets to eat finger food and feel like one of the grown ups while we both eat our food. Even if we had no interest in kiddo learning to self-feed, we'd go with finger food just because it buys us time to eat in peace.
 
Personally I don't understand wanting to start early as solids are a lot of hassle! It was so much easier when I only had to prepare feeds throughout the day. I was happy to wait until nearly six months as milk is so much easier!

I personally don't believe in not doing something for my child just because it isn't easy. But to each their own! :)

It's true - solids *are* a lot of work. Take a trip out, for example: previously it was prepare enough bottles and formula for LO; now it is prepare bottles and formula, plus snacks. Will we be out for lunch? Where are we going? LO is BLW but there is still salt content to consider so I prepare a back up lunch in case what we have isn't suitable. Oh and let's not forget the packets of wipes to clean surfaces and unhygienic highchairs... Plus food often gets on the floor and LO needs cleaning afterwards. I have no idea how it would work if purées were involved - maybe some defrosting and heating? I dunno! Whereas with milk it was simply mix formula, feed baby and burp! My thoughts are simply that a lot of parents are in a rush to wean as it's new and exciting (I couldn't wait and it was tough to get to nearly six months) but it comes with its own set of hassles.

On the plus side, now LO is weaned going out for lunch is loads of fun as he loves sitting at the table and eating with us. We get to eat (share) our lunch with a happy (greedy) baby and there's no fussing because he's bored!

Kiddo will eat both finger foods and puree cool when we're out. (as adults, we eat our fruits and veg cold quite often- if you're baby's willing, no reason not to) We're college students so 2-3 of our meals are out of home most days, and our college rarely has baby-safe foods (once in a blue moon). So:

-Container with teething biscuits
-Jar of storebought puree
-Container with fruit/veg finger food
-Container with home made puree
-Spoons. So many spoons.

(the storebought puree can be left at room temp unless open. The last two should go in a cooler of some sort. Everything except the spoons is optional, it's a mix and match of what we have ready and available.)

Those are four small containers, sometimes in a cooler- which you often need when dealing with bottles anyways- sometimes not. The wipes you need to deal with cleaning up after diaper changes or after going potty if you're doing EC anyways and, frankly, are a good idea with a baby. Unless your baby is a positively meticulous bottle feeder, you need to wipe milk off their faces either way.

I really don't find it any more difficult, especially with eating out. Thanks to BLW it's actually WAY easier. Now, instead of having to take turns on which adult gets to eat while the other holds and entertains the baby, kiddo gets to eat finger food and feel like one of the grown ups while we both eat our food. Even if we had no interest in kiddo learning to self-feed, we'd go with finger food just because it buys us time to eat in peace.

I suppose it isn't more difficult, it's the preparation that is another job to the list!

BLW is extremely easy though when eating out. Even just going for a coffee is less hassle now in the sense that LO will have a snack and it keeps him busy!
 
I suppose it isn't more difficult, it's the preparation that is another job to the list!

BLW is extremely easy though when eating out. Even just going for a coffee is less hassle now in the sense that LO will have a snack and it keeps him busy!

Purees require prep as well. Steamed fruit/veg- peel, cube, steam, mash/puree. Steamed fruit/veg finger food- peel, cut into the right size, steam, done. One less step and far less clean up required. You can cook proper foods for puree as well- stews, sauces, etc- and then you again have the added step of pureeing it after the fact then having to clean the blender.

Finger foods are more likely to be complicated than purees, but purees have an additional step over their finger food counterparts. Purees are also far less likely to be part of a meal that you're making for the grown ups in the house, which means that they require separate preparation more often.

If you want to argue about storebought purees- well, there are storebought finger foods as well.
 
I suppose it isn't more difficult, it's the preparation that is another job to the list!

BLW is extremely easy though when eating out. Even just going for a coffee is less hassle now in the sense that LO will have a snack and it keeps him busy!

Purees require prep as well. Steamed fruit/veg- peel, cube, steam, mash/puree. Steamed fruit/veg finger food- peel, cut into the right size, steam, done. One less step and far less clean up required. You can cook proper foods for puree as well- stews, sauces, etc- and then you again have the added step of pureeing it after the fact then having to clean the blender.

Finger foods are more likely to be complicated than purees, but purees have an additional step over their finger food counterparts. Purees are also far less likely to be part of a meal that you're making for the grown ups in the house, which means that they require separate preparation more often.

If you want to argue about storebought purees- well, there are storebought finger foods as well.

This was the main attraction to BLW for us - we just cook a meal and save LO a portion for his lunch the following day. Breakfast is great as LO and I eat the same thing and sit down together. Purées sound like way more hassle as I hate blending things!
 
My son is four months. The other day the pediatrician gave us the okay, but not just the okay. He said our son needs to eat the solids right now. He was eating formula at 4oz every 2 hours. The amount of 8oz every 4 hours is okay with our pediatrician, but not 4oz every 2 hours. We just started him on rice cereal and he hated it. We were told it is a recommendation to start on that, not a requirement. We skipped to carrots and he loved them and today, he had pears. I think he might like them even more. Anyways, I was wondering, as I don't hear many people starting out on four months anymore, but us starting on solids was a pediatrician's recommendation based on my son's feeding schedule. Don't let anyone judge you. If your pediatrician says it is okay and you think it is okay, go for it. I would look up a lot of solid feeding articles, though. We did!
 
My son is four months. The other day the pediatrician gave us the okay, but not just the okay. He said our son needs to eat the solids right now. He was eating formula at 4oz every 2 hours. The amount of 8oz every 4 hours is okay with our pediatrician, but not 4oz every 2 hours. We just started him on rice cereal and he hated it. We were told it is a recommendation to start on that, not a requirement. We skipped to carrots and he loved them and today, he had pears. I think he might like them even more. Anyways, I was wondering, as I don't hear many people starting out on four months anymore, but us starting on solids was a pediatrician's recommendation based on my son's feeding schedule. Don't let anyone judge you. If your pediatrician says it is okay and you think it is okay, go for it. I would look up a lot of solid feeding articles, though. We did!

I would be looking for a better doctor, one with a clue!

Why on earth is it not okay to feed every 2 hours? Has this doctor never met a baby before?
 
My LO has always eaten every two hours, and more than 4oz too! I'm with Rachel_C on this one, your Dr sounds useless.
 
I started Nathan at 18 weeks - a week after the minimum they say you can here in the UK.

Once he got started he never looked back - and is a fab eater normally.

Each baby is different so if you think they are ready, they probably *are*.
 
I started my first at 19 weeks and my second at 20 weeks ( earliest you can start is 17 weeks). Both were sitting well ( unaided by 5 months), able to pick up food and very interested. For me I can't imagine waiting til 6 months because they were so ready for it but each baby is different. Do what you feel is best x
 
I started with my ds last Sunday. He was 19 weeks. I had been deliberating for a couple of weeks, especially with the guidelines being 6 months. But, I am now so pleased we have started. My ds is loving it! He hasn't turned his nose up at anything (he's had baby rice, sweet potato, carrot and banana). As soon as I put him in his high chair I get massive smiles from him. My ds was showing sign of being ready and is a big baby (we're about to move into 9-12 month clothes). So, for us it was right. Every baby is different, though, but my advice would be to follow what you think is right. Do you think your baby would benefit from weaning at this stage? Follow your gut, you know your baby. Oh, and yes, it may be a bit more work, but worth every second (and I steamed a load, froze it and just pop it in the fridge in the evening ready for the next day - it's not much more work at all!!).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,308
Messages
27,144,991
Members
255,759
Latest member
boom2211
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"
<-- Admiral -->