Great choices, we also love Edith and Eve, we were leaning towards using Edith and calling her Edie but have been put off by reactions from others and may now go with Eve/Evie
People have mentioned it rhyming with needy and greedy
It kind of looks like eddy the boys name when being read
As she gets older will edie begin to sound childish and then being Edith be a bit formal?
Evie is cute and then if she wanted to be more professional Eve maybe works better?
Sorry, probably looking into it way too much but would be great to hear others thoughts?