Am I justified or being irrational?

I don't know any mother that would leave their 5 month old with someone they didn't know overnight! For a couple hours, yeah if the other spouse was confident in them. Although I do understand some don't want to even do that..which is up to them.

But overnight..that is unreasonable. Mine is 15 months and hasn't been somewhere overnight but when he does it will probably only be with grandparents and aunts.
 
Nope, not a chance in hell.
The only people I'd trust my son with overnight is my mum and MIL, partly because they've always been around him and know how to settle him- he can be extremely high needs at times- and also because I know that I can trust them to do what I tell them in regards to my child.
My son hates being with people he doesn't know, my friend held him while I went to the toilet for a quick pee and he started howling!
 
It wouldn't have been possible for me to leave either boy at 5 months as I was still BF round the clock, I do leave them overnight with my mum when needed but I wouldn't do it with someone like you describe. It's a shame, I can see why your hubby is disappointed but he's being unrealistic.
 
^^ same, she was still constantly feeding at that age and slept in bed with me. (actually, not much has changed really :rofl:)
 
The only people I'd leave my kids with overnight is my mum and my sister.

Could you arrange your own babysitter? Find someone now who you trust and get her to meet and get to know your lo now, in advance? Then ask her to babysit your lo in your own home on the night?
 
I know he wants the two of you to spend the night alone, but if he know you're not comfortable, would he still be comfortable with the three of you staying overnight? (You, him and LO). Someone can watch him for the dinner portion, then you can pick him up and still enjoy the perk of the hotel room.
 
I wouldn't do it, my son is 4 months and I still haven't left him with anyone not even family, so there is no way I would leave him with strangers. Your husband is being unreasonable. I hope he will eventually see where your coming from.
 
Oh gosh, no, hun, your husband is the one being irrational...or really, and I'm assuming here that this is your first, he just doesn't get it yet or realise how involved parenting has to be. My daughter is nearly 2 and she's never stayed overnight with anyone yet except my husband and I. We've visiting my family in another month, which will be just after her 2nd birthday, and she might, might, as I'm still not 100% comfortable with it, stay with grandma for a night while we get a night out and stay over in a hotel. Our daughter never even stayed with another person during the evening so we could have dinner until she was 7 months old - and that was with my mum. There is no way in heck I'd ever leave her with someone I barely knew, even when she's like 8! At 5 months, they are still so vulnerable and need a lot of attention at night, which even if you assume it would be okay for her to stay overnight with someone else, probably isn't fair on these distant acquaintances as it's likely they might have to be up all night with her. I wouldn't expect that of anyone else personally. I think it's all fair to say it's nice to have a night out and you ought to do that if you have friends or family nearby who you know and trust with her. But I wouldn't feel comfortable leaving a baby that age with anyone, but especially not strangers.

In this case, I would offer him the chance to go on his own and enjoy a night out and stay over with his work friends if it's important that he goes and stays the whole night. No one could legitimately think you're being a jerk for being at home with your child in a situation like that. My husband went by himself to a close friend's wedding for the weekend when our daughter was about 4 months old. There was no way we could leave her as we don't have family nearby or anyone who could even watch her, not that I would have wanted to anyway, and it was a no kids wedding so we couldn't bring her. Or alternatively, you could ask someone you trust to watch her in the evening and just go for the dinner bit and take a taxi home. That way you can support him, but still be home to do the nighttime parenting. Yes, it's nice to have time away together as a couple, but I think there's a time for that, and I know at 5 months, we hadn't reached that point where it was possible. I think he probably just needs to be a bit more patient and understanding that time's have changed and things don't work the way they used to - though I assure you, you will be able to do those sorts of things again one day and enjoy them because you'll feel comfortable with who is taking care of your LO.
 
No I would not, I struggled leaving my oldest with people I trust so certainly wouldn't with strangers. I certainly wouldn't do it that young
 
Saying that I wouldn't leave my los with strangers at any age (obviously don't mean nursery or school)
 
I don't think you're being irrational at all! I wouldn't leave my daughter with someone I didn't know well enough to trust, and she's not a baby any more, she's 2. In fact, my good friend offered to have her a couple of weeks ago, and I politely said no. I only trust a few family members to babysit. :) x
 
I would not do it either not my 17 month old dd (especially with a co- worker I hardly know) let alone a 5 month old..
 
Not a chance...........only with grandparents would I even consider it.

And honestly, I think if you went ahead with it and left him, you wouldnt have a good night anyways as you would be worrying too much about it.
 
My DD stayed overnight with my MIL at a little over a month old when I went to a concert in a different state. She's the only one I would allow for her to stay overnight with because no one else knows DD as well as she does for not being the parent

The only way I would allow the coworker to watch DD is if they spent plenty of time with her. February is over 2 months away. But that's just me. If they weren't willing to spend time with her and learn to settle her then I wouldn't agree to it. DH can have fun without me.
 
I think he is being unfair. A 5 month old will start to recognize who is looking after him and to leave him with someone he does not know and you do not know just for a night out is unreasonable.

I would not leave my 6 year old overnight with someone she had not met before as she would not like it at all neither would her brother. They need to be with someone they know and trust - for my 2 year old at the moment that is just his grandparents for my 6 year old it also includes 2 or three of her friends mums as well.

Not only that but taking responsiblity of a baby that you have not met is also too much, I would happily have overnight or look after (and have) my 6 year old friends who know me and I have taken one of DS friends as well but I know them and their personalities.

I think he just has to accept its bad timing with your mum neing in mexico. If you are happy for her to have him overnight maybe try and arrange another date night
 
Your husband is being ridiculous. my 2 year old has only ever stayed in her grandparents house, and my 4 month old has not stayed out yet as I'm still not comfortable with it. expecting you to leave your baby for the first time with people you don't even know is being unreasonable! I would let him go alone and you two have a night together when your mum can do the babysitting xx
 
LOL Being unreasonable?? He's being ludicrous!!!

I'd never leave my baby with a stranger like that. I can't even leave him overnight with anyone yet and he's 5.5 months.

Don't feel bad, and trust your heart. :hugs:
 
Hell no, I wouldn't do it. I wouldn't even consider leaving my two year old with a stranger. In fact, I wouldn't even leave a responsible 12 year old over night with strangers.

Your OH is being unreasonable. Do not allow him to make you feel bad or push you into this.
 
Hell no it wouldnt be happening and id have put my oh in his place too about it for putting his wants before babies needs!. I dont trust anyone to watch my boys (apart from nursery and im even jumpy about that too!). My mum had ds1 overnight at 2 and a half weeks old and i HATED it! Since then shes had ds1 twice.. once for 2 hours while we went for a meal.. and once with my sister from 9am - 1pm while i had my c-section with ds2 and thats it. DS2 has never been away from me.

And i would never ever allow a stranger to have my child no matter how well dh knew them. If i've not met them that means the children haven't met them. And i would never ever leave my child with someone they dont know. xx
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,320
Messages
27,146,050
Members
255,778
Latest member
hague93
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"
<-- Admiral -->