"Boy" or "Girl" name as girl or boy middle name? Opinions

[bassdesire]

Anyone have thoughts on using a "boyish" name as a girl's middle name?

We might want to use two family names:

Irving

Zelda

So these would be middle name options, but we haven't decided which...I like the idea of using Irving as a girl's middle name--does that bother you?

Example:

girl=Adina Irving Goldberg
boy=Elliott Irving Berkowitz

OR

girl=Orli Zelda Goldberg
boy=Cale Zelda Goldberg

I think Irving works with both but I am not sure about Zelda...

thoughts??????

 

[Mrs.Craig]

Anyone have thoughts on using a "boyish" name as a girl's middle name?

We might want to use two family names:

Irving

Zelda

So these would be middle name options, but we haven't decided which...I like the idea of using Irving as a girl's middle name--does that bother you?

Example:

girl=Adina Irving Goldberg
boy=Elliott Irving Berkowitz

OR

girl=Orli Zelda Goldberg
boy=Cale Zelda Goldberg

I think Irving works with both but I am not sure about Zelda...

thoughts??????

i LOVE the names Cale and Adina. but im not sure about Irving. its really different though. we wanna name our daughter Devyn like Devin. So i guess it depends on you. Im sorta liking Zelda for a boy. its sorta like Ezra!

 

[bassdesire]

Like Zelda for the middle name or the first name??

They are family names so we are thinking to use them to honor family...

 

[Mrs.Craig]

i like it for a middle name. how you have it.

 

[sjxoxo]

I'm not sure about Zelda for a boy, but I really like it for a girl.