Erica did this too at first. My cousin gave me a couple jars of stage 3 jars, that she had from her son who can now eat more solid foods. She gagged, spit the chunks out, and didn't want to eat it. Now I'm slowly introducing thicker foods, using the stage 3 jars. I'm mixing like 1/3 of the jar, with her homemade fruits or veggies that are not chunky at all. Its thicker than the stage 2, but not quite as thick as stage 3. She is now making the chewing motions, and is getting more and more used to it. Josh is getting sooo big! He is so cute!!