was chinese gender/lunar prediction wrong for anyone??

[tink28]

those who have previously had children or already know the sex of their babies may be able to help me out with this one.

i am seriously struggling to see how the chinese gender predictor or the zodiac lunar one (to do with the moon phases) can logically work for anyone? as i dont see how a womans lunar age or what the moon is doing at the time of conception can influence whether a X or Y sperm fertilises the egg??

i did both of them and they have both given me a prediction of girl (im guessing both work things out the same somehow) but when i worked them back for me, i should of apparently been a boy!

however i keep hearing how successful this is for like 9/10 people. just wondered if theres anyone its been wrong for?

 

[zoe87]

the general chinease predictor charts was wrong for me, but when someone told me u have to use your lunar age it was right.

 

[Dragonfly]

post link as there are two one was wrong and one right.

 

[tink28]

this is the lunar/magic horoscope one

https://www.magic-horoscope.com/child_gender/index.php

and this is the chinese one

https://www.babygenderprediction.com/chinese-gender-chart.html

 

[destinyfaith]

it prodicted a girl for me and which im having a boy ! well im thinking i am lol sonographer wasnt a 100% but was pretty sure x

 

[HopefulMi]

One says girl for me and one says boy!

 

[Dragonfly]

this is the lunar/magic horoscope one

https://www.magic-horoscope.com/child_gender/index.php

and this is the chinese one

https://www.babygenderprediction.com/chinese-gender-chart.html

luner one was wrong says William should be a girl. Says this one is a boy which I dont know yet,. But guess thats wrong.

And chinese ones says William is suppose to be a girl. And says this one is a girl also so I guess the other way and go boy.

 

[kimberley_80]

Both said girl and I'm having a boy I'd rather trust the scan tecnolagy than the chart lol. My last pregnancy they all came back boy and I had a girl x

 

[EmzyJA]

i think it's all a load of rubbish. i did one before and it said boy for me but i found out yesterday our LO is a girl x

 

[jmbbf]

they both worked for me. have you tried the moon theory? heard it was right for most women on here

 

[Lina]

These charts are rubbish. You find that one chinese chart predicts a boy, and another a girl.

 

[SBB]

It was wrong for me!

X x x

 

[Ju_bubbs]

both those links are wrong for me!

 

[tink28]

jmbbf-whats the moon theory? is it the same as the magic horoscope link, as i think thats based on moon phases?

 

[Tigerlass]

I think its all a bit of an old wives tale lol! ( Just like the whole " dangle a ring over belly " story ).... Theres no way on earth really that a calender of any sort can predict the gender. It was wrong with my sisters one and my SIL... It's nice to have a play I guess but in reality its all rubbish lol
One calender says I'm predicted a girl and the other says a boy! Well I have my gender scan in a couple of weeks so I will see which one is right haha!

 

[miamix]

Post deleted

 

[natlee]

the chinese one got it right for my son and wrong for my new little man .. they said he was a girl and clearly is not from the scan yday lol!! x

 

[Catters]

Both of those were wrong for me.. the ONLY thing that was right was the Iridology thing (the fishhook looking veins in my eyes bit).. but again, could be a fluke..

 

[jmbbf]

sorry tink yes its the magic horoscope one. there was a thread on here a few weeks ago and a majority of people were correct. i believe it to some extent but its still only 50/50 right lol x

 

[InvisibleRain]

The Chinese Predictors were RIGHT for me hun, they were Girl all excepted the ones that asked for my Last Mens cycle... and that was only 2 that said boy. All the others said Girl.... and I have a darling lil Dudette!