A question for American gals

P

Pandora11

Guest
What is a scone supposed to taste like/be like? I'm trying to find the right recipe for the type of scones i had when i was in the USA, and there seems to be a lot of them and it's hard to tell by the pictures. The kind i'm looking for were crunchy and buttery, any ideas?

For us English girls - American scones taste nothing like ours, i thought they tasted like something between a biscuit and a baby rusk!

Confused
 
Sorry not American but interested, I never encountered an American scone. I had a "biscuit" which was a bit like our version of a scone but savoury.
 
Well I've had scones from Starbucks and I've made them several times but they weren't crunchy. To me that would be gross. I've made blueberry scones, and this is the recipe I've used. Doesn't have to be this brand flour. These are very yummy. :)

https://www.tasteofhome.com/Recipes/Blueberry-Scones
 
What is a scone supposed to taste like/be like? I'm trying to find the right recipe for the type of scones i had when i was in the USA, and there seems to be a lot of them and it's hard to tell by the pictures. The kind i'm looking for were crunchy and buttery, any ideas?

For us English girls - American scones taste nothing like ours, i thought they tasted like something between a biscuit and a baby rusk!

Confused

Think you might be referring to what Americans call a biscuit, which is often eaten with chicken I believe
 
What is a scone supposed to taste like/be like? I'm trying to find the right recipe for the type of scones i had when i was in the USA, and there seems to be a lot of them and it's hard to tell by the pictures. The kind i'm looking for were crunchy and buttery, any ideas?

For us English girls - American scones taste nothing like ours, i thought they tasted like something between a biscuit and a baby rusk!

Confused

Think you might be referring to what Americans call a biscuit, which is often eaten with chicken I believe

Maybe I'm getting confused then, I thought biscuits were soft?
 
We have dinner rolls that can look like a biscuit and be on the harder side. Here in the south we tend to smother our bread in either butter, gravy, or homemade jam. Never had a scone, no idea where to even find a place around here that makes them!
 
The scones I've had here are soft on the inside, but tend to be a bit crunchy on the outside. Not bad crunchy, crunchy as in from being baked. Biscuits, especially drier dessert (blueberry) biscuits, have a texture pretty similar to scones. Hope that helps, OP. And for the US girls, Panera sells cinnamon chip scones which are delicious.
 
Their more soft on the inside and a bit more dry on the outside kind if like a soft cookie. They shouldn't be really crumbly.
 
If you mean biscuits, this recipe looked good.

https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/southern-biscuits-recipe/index.html

like thishttps://sweeticedtea.files.wordpress.com/2010/09/biscuit.jpg

If you mean something else, than I have no idea!
 
If you mean biscuits, this recipe looked good.

https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/southern-biscuits-recipe/index.html

like thishttps://sweeticedtea.files.wordpress.com/2010/09/biscuit.jpg

If you mean something else, than I have no idea!

To me that's a scone not a biscuit.. Confused :wacko: x
 
If you mean biscuits, this recipe looked good.

https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/southern-biscuits-recipe/index.html

like thishttps://sweeticedtea.files.wordpress.com/2010/09/biscuit.jpg

If you mean something else, than I have no idea!

To me that's a scone not a biscuit.. Confused :wacko: x

In America (especially the South) that is a biscuit. What you call biscuits, we call cookies. Scones are usually sweet, with fruit maybe.

Yeah, us American's are weird ;)
 
Yeh that's what I thought a biscuit was, they were pretty popular in Mississippi when I was there!
 
Now I'm really curious to know what OP is asking about, lol. Scones, biscuits, cookies...now I'm hungry and on a GD diet. Thanks, ladies ;)
 
Okay, as an Australian who lives in the US now, let me see if I can sort out the confusion for everyone. :haha:

Commonwealth scone is approximately American biscuit. In the US, they are usually eaten with savoury things, kind of taking the place of a dinner roll. They're eaten buttered with dinner, or covered in gravy. In the Commonwealth, they are usually eaten with sweet things, for afternoon tea for instance, with cream and jam. The recipes may differ slightly, but the concept is the same - light, fluffy bland-tasting thing used as a vehicle to deliver yummier things to your mouth.

https://thebarking.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/biscuit.jpg

American scone doesn't really have a Commonwealth equivalent. It's kind of like a larger, denser Commonwealth scone, more cake-like than light and fluffy, with fruit on the inside, sometimes sugar on the outside, and cooked so that the outside is harder than the inside.

https://blogs.babble.com/family-kitchen/files/2011/03/Blueberry-Scones1.jpg

Commonwealth biscuit is the same as American cookie. In Australia we use cookie as well, specifically to mean the choc-chip cookie-style cookie. Anything that's more shortbread like, or cream- or jam-filled (like the picture below), is a biscuit (or even a bikkie) - I'm not sure if that's the same in the UK.

https://www.deweys.com/managed/bakery-cookies.jpg
 
lol thanks for your replies. What i was given at a hotel looked like the starbucks photo but were crunchy... the women who made them (American) called them scones. They were definitely triangle and crunchy. who knows, maybe they were just overcooked?! lol

I tried this recipe https://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Grand...11=scones&e8=Quick Search&event10=1&e7=Recipe, but they were too soft and taste like English current/rock cakes.

When i mentioned they tasted like biscuit i meant the English kind.


to pp, lol, you're on the ball. We say the same as you.

We should have an international recipe thread...i'm starving now.
 
Oh, i have a question while you are all still here... why do you put marshmallow in casserole? Is casserole the same as the English ones and what does it taste like?!

Ohh, one more... why can't you buy a bacon sandwich in America?(maybe you can, just i couldn't find one) Why is bacon only in teeny tiny pieces and used as a topping on stuff? x
 
Oh, i have a question while you are all still here... why do you put marshmallow in casserole? Is casserole the same as the English ones and what does it taste like?!

Ohh, one more... why can't you buy a bacon sandwich in America?(maybe you can, just i couldn't find one) Why is bacon only in teeny tiny pieces and used as a topping on stuff? x

LOL!!! Um, I've never put marshmallows on a casserole, maybe a dessert casserole? Casseroles are much more savory than sweet. In fact, I made pizza casserole for dinner tonight. That would not be good with marshmallows. The only thing I've seen with marshmallows is yams at the holidays. Casserole can pretty much taste like anything. In general, it's a meat, a sauce, a pasta or bread or binder of some kind, maybe some veg....like tuna casserole. I made pizza casserole, primal style, aka no grains. So basically like pizza without the crust, in a casserole dish, in the oven.

Yes, bacon is much thinner here I have found. You can get a bacon sandwich, its called a BLT (bacon, lettuce, tomato, usually with mayo). But not everywhere has them.

Our bacon is different. It's pork belly bacon, or streaky bacon. I think in the UK it's usually back bacon, which is much meatier and less fatty. I think....or at least wikipedia says so....

Bacon is delicious. Why have it on a sandwich when you can just have bacon by itself? Mmmm...that reminds me. I ate the last of the bacon for breakfast. Damn. No breakfast bacon tomorrow.
 
Good god, this is kind of like who's on first.

Edit: found this picture on Pinterest and thought it might help :)
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    17.8 KB · Views: 24

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,282
Messages
27,143,581
Members
255,745
Latest member
mnmorrison79
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"
<-- Admiral -->