I haven't decided what I want to do yet. The other day I suddenly felt determined to do a VBAC but today I chickened out again and want an elective. I'm not afraid of rupture as the risk is so minimal but I'm just afraid I'll come close to losing LO again but not get the happy ending this time. And logistically, it's easier to plan around an elective. You have a fair idea of when the baby is coming, you don't need to call the sitter at 2 in the morning, etc. Even though my previous section was an emergency, I had a good experience overall and don't really have any regrets. I honestly don't care if I have to go through another section. I know what recovery is like so I don't need to hear "oh, it's so hard on your body".
My OB says it is totally up to me at this point but at our hospital I have to go into the high-risk ward if I want a VBAC so that means constant fetal monitoring and limited birthing options. You have to ask someone to unhook you from the machines if you have to pee, you can't walk around or use the water tubs to relax, you have to push lying down (the hospital is otherwise good about letting you kneel, sit, whatever) etc.
Also, our hospital has a lowish VBAC rate (under 40%) so I don't want to have to labour only to end up with a section anyways.
DH wants me to have an elective but he says he knows it's not up to him as I"m the one who has to go through with it.