I like A Christmas Carol, Lexi sort of likes it, she feels so big reading it but it's not really for 4 year olds. Other than that we've bought her the grinch who stole Christmas for Christmas Eve, and it was buy one get one half price so we got her Elmer's Christmas which we gave to her early, she loves Elmer books and it's the only one she didn't have. She's only just gotten into reading this year, and I'm so happy she enjoys it!