Hello. I'm a Daddy, but I'd like to tell you about our successful first baby homebirth. Our little Eliza was born at 33 minutes past midnight on her due date, 28th August 2011.
Labor lasted 3 1/2 hrs, and my amazing wife used no pain relief whatsoever. It wasn't easy, but she was so brave and determined that she wanted a natural birth, and it was amazing. She doesn't feel that she could have done this if she had been in hospital, because she would have been far less relaxed.
We had a La Bassine birth pool at home, and everything went so well. She needed a few stitches afterwards, and this went very smoothly, and although that was what she was dreading most, it didn't bother her at all, as our lovely little girl was in her Daddy's arms by then!
The midwives were amazing, and we got lucky with THREE midwives AND a student, so we had far more attention than you would ever have in a hospital. This was a fluke though - the first midwife's shift ended at midnight, but when her replacement arrived the birth had progressed so quickly, she stayed on.
I really couldn't recommend a home birth enough. I was kept busy throughout, boiling pans for hot water for the pool, fetching things for the midwives and so on, and didn't suffer from the spare part syndrome many dad's feel during the birth, so I think that's another plus. Dad's are in their own environment, and can therefore feel and be much more involved and useful.
Obviously things can go wrong, but they can also go wrong at hospital. I think the only real downside to homebirths for a straightforward pregnancy is the fear that it might not happen due to resourcing issues. We were very lucky to get ours, as the local maternity unit was really busy all day and if we had been an hour or two earlier, there just wouldn't have been enough midwives to see to us and they would have asked us to come in. We would have fought to stay at home and tried to insist that they find bank staff to cover the hospital, but it would have been very stressful and unpleasant, and as labor progressed so quickly, it would have been real stress.
But apart from that last problem, if you think you want a homebirth, I say just go for it. We are proof that they can be very successful.
My other half is not a member on B&B, but if you have any questions about it, please post and I'll ask her to answer!
Good luck with your homebirths!