We had that same problem! Went through at least 20 names that I liked, hubby shot them ALL down! He kept giving me names that were either from our generation or older (like Nick, Shawn, Cody, John ect) and I wanted something not so popular and not TOO old.. We finally agreed on Spencer (not quite new but not too old sounding and not super popular here either) then originally agreed on Jacob for a middle name but changed it to Jasyn, I liked it better and Jacob was too twilight for hubby anyway LOL. After that we agreed if the next was a girl I would pick and if it was a boy he would pick. Our 2nd was a girl - her name is Emery Bay.
This time around I think we've agreed on Cora for a girl (he wants to spell it Korra though but I don't like that spelling - but we have time to debate that one!) As for a boy I'd come up with Liam Jett (Jett was the name he wanted for a boy) he still wants Jett as a first name but doesn't like the middle name he originally chose anymore.. honestly I think Jett works better as a middle name.. EVERY name he tosses out or that I think of sounds ridiculous (Jett Li - NO lol) Jett Lane? Cute but reminds me of an airport.. Same with Jett Skylar.. The original was Jett Danger.. He wanted to name our first kid that actually (so he could teach him to say Danger is my middle name) but I vetoed it back then I have to say though while waiting to find out if our 2nd was a boy or a girl it did grow on me but it sounds like a name out of a comic book! Anyway most of the names we thought of sound silly or sound better with Jett as a middle name.. Liam Jett flows better than Jett Liam to me.. (which is what hubby suggested because like I said he wants Jett as a first name but then he's all like Spencer can have my first initial and this kid can have my middle initial) face palm moment really.. Jett Ryan is ok I guess but not sold on it at all.. more reason to hope for another girl!