ahh Broody/squashy I feel for you guys, I feel like I'm reading something that I wrote about 10 years ago!
My ex-husband and I were a great couple, very good friends. He wasn't sure he wanted kids... 5 years into our relationship we almost broke up. I told him that I wanted kids and if he didn't then that was a deal breaker... he said he just wasn't ready.. fast forward a few years, he says okay I'm ready, I'm pregnant 3 months later...he left when my ds was 3 months old (we had been together 11 years). He really didn't want kids, I should have listened to him... I just didn't believe him since he has always been great with kids. Now i don't regret anything since I wouldn't have my ds and he is amazing. Now i think my ex has it the way he wanted it, he gets to be a dad, but still gets to have his "normal" life... He was a terrible dad for a very long time.. ever since my ds turned 4 (he's now 7) things got much better and my ds doesn't remember those bad years.
Bottom line, listen to your heart, and be honest with yourself, decide if you could truly be happy without being a mom... it's a hard one believe me, i've been there, and I wasn't strong enough to be honest with myself.. I just always believed he'd come around...
I hope I haven't been to harsh, not meant to be
Good luck!
Kim