I truly hate that the word "abuse" gets bantered about so lightly. Every form of discipline is "abuse" to somebody. It's silly and insulting to those who are truly, truly being abused. Also wastes social services' time chasing these frivolous accusations when there are children with real needs. But no, mommies who use any form of CIO, give their kids juice, use playpens, or potty train before the kid "wants" to is an "abuser". Really, anyone who doesn't do what THEY do is an abuser.
I can't STAND this!!! I think DH and I are good parents and yet I constantly find myself thinking, "I bet if anyone could see/hear this right now, they would probably think we're awful parents!" There is so much judgment directed at parents, it's ridiculous.
And the overuse of the word "abuse" drives me crazy. Last fall, one of my good friends from high school was pregnant with her second child. Her first--who is almost 3--is autistic. One of his teachers who comes to their house told her that she was abusive because she locked him in his room for 10 minutes as a "time out" when he hit her or threw the remote control at her!!!! I was so angry! Here is my poor friend who's a heavily pregnant SAHM with a violent special needs child and this woman is telling her she's abusive because she puts the kid in a time out!?? (And by the way, seriously, would an abusive parent pay money to HAVE the teacher at the house in the first place?? I don't think so!!)
Gah. I get so angry every time I think about it.
I joined a fb group called gentle dicipline , I don't agree with slapping or physical chastisement ( thought this is what the group was about ! ) boy was I wrong !!!! Extremists !!! They don't believe in dicipline at all !!!' No consequences for mos behaviour !! Its all about understanding your child's behaviour related to their emotions which they can't handle and that is what results in misbehaviour . So they do not believe in any form of correction . I got into soo much trouble with some of my comments before I understood what the group was about lol.......
I can see where understanding your child's behavior can be useful, but understanding the behavior doesn't mean it doesn't have consequences. As an example, I'm a prosecutor, so I have cases where it's clear WHY the defendant broke the law, but understanding WHY they did what they did does not mean that I don't charge them. I understand I'm talking about adults, but I think the principle is largely the same.
And I don't think we give kids nowadays nearly enough credit. I understand there are real developmental milestones (so LO won't understand abstract theoreticals at 1 year old, no matter how hard I try), but IMO, we also baby kids for way too long. Just look at the helicopter parents who do EVERYTHING for their kids, even when their "kids" are in their 20s and 30s!
I just think several decades ago kids were more disciplined, so they're obviously capable of more than we expect now. Just my opinion, obviously!