Finlay's a 'nip-er in the bud-er'. Even now we have to get in quick before the scream takes hold. If we let him cry he would just suck air in and get windier. I had huge issues with the in laws early on about how we (I) dealt with things. They would let him cry and jig and pat and piss him off. I wasn't allowed to comfort him. I was made to feel like I was controlling and over powering. I may have been, but I knew that letting him cry made things a hundred times worse. Of course sometimes I couldn't soothe him and he would cry inconsolably or other times I would need to let him cry for practical reasons but as a rule I tried not to where possible. I wouldn't say I'm a 'gentle' parent. I'm much more matter of fact as a person, but you know your own child and what works. Also guidelines don't tend to promote sleep training until after 6mths so officially its too early if anyone is trying to push you that way.