I miss one day for being sick and too much to catch up on lol! I didn't fully read everything, so my apologies.
I have to be the odd one out here with Gibs. I do spank Kash when it is needed, and we do raise our voice at him if he is doing something that is going to hurt himself. We sternly tell him no. If he keeps doing something when he is asked not to, he will get a spank on the butt. Now, this is not a full blown act of violence, this is a tap on the butt, which is covered by a diaper. I was spanked as a kid, and I believe in it.
When Kash was biting me, he would get bit back and he would get tapped on the mouth. He no longer bites, and only bit a few times. He learned it is not nice to bite and it hurts.
We use our words with Kash as well. Say when he is ripping books, we say Kash books are for reading, not ripping. We have to treat our books nicely, otherwise we won't have any to read.
We do not do time outs, as they simply are too young to understand what these are at this age. When he is older and understands what a time out means, he will be getting those too.
I'm sorry if you all think I am wrong about how I discipline my child, but we all need to do what works for us. All children respond differently to different kinds of discipline, and what works for some, will not work for others. The fact is, you need to be consistent with whatever form you choose
And I can say too, when Kash continues to disobey what we ask him to do or not do, all I have to say is do you want a spank and he says no and listens. He knows what a spank is and that it means you are in trouble.