ok MA think I can help (or at least let you know what WE'RE doing this year) a little...
I am one of 8 siblings, 4 are partnered up, with my LO there will be 8 grandchildren
DH is one of 3 siblings, 3 partners, no children,
Both our parents are still together
So over the years we have had argument after argument from the inlaws about where we should spend christmas.. Now i've ALWAYS gone to midnight mass with my parents and family at our local church (where DH and I married), and we've always wanted to continue this tradition. Over the years we have tried to do christmas morning at one parent, christmas afternoon at the other (which is just a nightmare driving around on christmas day, it's no fun for anyone!)
Well my brothers and sisters come and go on different days over christmas, my mum finds out what day each sibling can visit and she does a "christmas dinner" on that day for them, complete with decorations, crackers etc. and it makes no difference if it's christmas eve or any time up to new years eve, anyone is welcome to come and have CHRISTMAS with the family without causing anyone any upset. We all get told when everyone is coming down and we can all go visit on that day too if we want...
Now DH's family....
they believe that we should be doing the following: (I kid you not....)
Christmas eve LUNCH - annual traditional pub lunch with all of DH's immediate and extended family (cousins etc.)
Christmas tea + midnight mass with MIL/FIL/2xSILs
Christmas day - ALL day at their house
Christmas night - buffet at DH's aunties house to see the extended family all again
Boxing day - ALL day at their house where they do a walk with their friends around the block and eat jacket potatoes when they get back
Boxing day night - drinks at their local pub
Now.. where in that list am I supposed to see MY family OR have our OWN family christmas!?!
so this is what we've been able to come up with and we're sticking to our guns...
Christmas eve lunch - traditional pub lunch with the inlaw extended family
Midnight mass with LO with my family at the church DH and I married in, the same church our LO will be christened in - with my family and DH's family is MORE than welcome to come and join us there
Christmas day we are spending at OUR house, the 3 of us (plus my niece obviously - long story for those who don't know [she's 18]). We will open our own presents with DH taking the role that my dad has always done - he will hand out the presents ONE AT A TIME from under the tree.
At 4pm on christmas day my parents, siblings, their children, are invited to ours for a buffet supper, we will hand out our presents traditionally (my dad will hand out these ones as he has always done for our family). Each person will have ONE. SMALL. present each (or often i/my siblings will do a hamper for eachother of homemade gifts per family - jams/chutneys/knitted scarves/jewellery etc.).
Now the reason why the presents are handed out by one person one at a time is so that everyone knows WHO their present is from, and has a chance to say thank you and appreciate each small gift they get - it's not a free for all under the christmas tree where noone knows who gave what (or cares for that matter
)
LO will be raised to appreciate each gift for what it is and to say thankyou to the person who was thoughtful enough to get her it, no matter WHAT it is, she won't be bought up that christmas is just for getting presents!!
On boxing day, DH's family can come over from the morning, we will do a traditional christmas day lunch, they can stay all day and leave when it is time for them to go to his aunties buffet dinner, we won't be going.
Between boxing day and new years DH and I will go to my parents if their is a sibling visiting who we haven't seen for a while..
Now my parents are ECSTATIC about this idea we've come up with, they think it's great that we'll have our OWN christmas (making our OWN traditions) but that also we are keeping some OLD traditions with the family. However DH's family are appalled and think we are being selfish...
So be it, we are happy with our choices and that by doing what we have planned we will be instilling in LO over the years the true importance of christmas.
So my advice would be to discuss with Doug what is important to YOU as a family unit with Amelia to experience over christmas, once you've decided what that is, go from there - make sure you get to see each side of the family at some point over christmas, but mainly make sure that you get to enjoy and celebrate your OWN special day together...