Rachel that's a fantastic night!!
What a great birthday present for you. Happy birthday!
Hope he behaves himself tonight too!
Amy, we have had a little bit of hysterical crying
mostly night 4 though. Night 1 it wasn't more than a few minutes of that IIRC. I just leave him, because if I pick him up and calm him and then put him down, he gets much much more upset...sounds like Chloe may be similar. The Sleep Lady's version allows you to do that if it helps, but I only did it once because it was clearly very counterproductive. So I just told him that I was there with him and loved him and it was time to sleep. I think I sang to him a little too.
He is a baby who gets worked up though. I don't think you had joined the thread before any of these instances, but he's cried for an hour and a half a few times in his life, and vomited from crying twice. I don't know whether that makes you feel better or worse
but really I was afraid of much worse than what happened with gradual withdrawal. Chances are you won't experience anything like that, especially given what has happened already when you've tried.
In the past week or so there have been a couple times when it's been clear that he's not even trying to SS, and I've picked him up to take a break or nurse some more. But that's because things feel better established now and I know he can do it if he's ready to, and I know what it looks like when he is trying. For the first week at least, I think it's important to be really consistent to give LO the best chance to learn.
He does have a lovey. I introduced it around 4 months but he's seemed more attached to it for the past few weeks, so I think it did help him learn to SS. It did take me a little while to get comfortable with the idea of him having it in his bed. Initially I was planning to give it to him as he was falling asleep and then remove it once he was asleep, but I woke him up a couple times that way and then gave up. Do you have a movement sensor? If so, maybe that would reassure your hubby?