Hey guys. Insomnia at least allows me to catch up a bit...
We had a really good morning (nights aren't the problem--the morning wake up is). J slept until quarter to 7, so that's a full 12 again. He did uncharacteristically wake at 2:30, though, but when OH went in, thinking it might be teething, J started giggling, so we firmly shut the door and let him CIO. Didn't take too long. Little rascal.
I know that CC is preferred to CIO, but I couldn't have done that with J. He would have just gotten more and more hysterical every time we would come in, prolonging the crying. With CIO, they know no one is coming, and while that sounds a bit cruel, maybe, psychologically, it's better in the end? One means that mummy is coming back soon, as long as I keep crying, while the other means, well, I'm on my own here, I'd better figure out a way to get to sleep... We are always there again in the morning, so they know we're not gone or that they've been abandoned... Just my two cents, though. You all know your babes better than I do, and I know J's temperament, which is actually a pretty pragmatic one. We've been CIO with naps, too, and although my husband can't do it, I can, so J knows that with OH, he'll be down again in a few minutes, but if mum put him to bed, there's no getting out of it. I don't even bother timing it anymore, as I know I put him down when he exhibited signs that he was tired, and he therefore will eventually sleep. Ever since I started doing that, we've stopped having the 3-5 pm meltdown and clinginess, and his mood is simply much, much better during the day. Though
Angel, I have no idea how one handles it with twins, unless you perhaps do complete CIO with both.
As for being inconsistent, I keep making this analogy for OH (I learned this in Behavioural Psych at uni): our cat will
always come if we shake the Turkey Treats bag, no matter if she gets some or not. (This is how we get her out of situations for which she most certainly will not be rewarded, but we cannot get her to come in any other way, like when she goes under the porch.) She comes because
sometimes she does gets treats when we shake the bag, and
maybe this time will be one of those times. Inconsistency leads to an understanding that
sometimes they will be rewarded, and
maybe, just
maybe this is one of those times.
I know you guys probably want to slap me right now, and I know that I'm meddling where I don't belong. And maybe it is simply J's personality that allows us to do CIO, but it worked. If he does cry during the night, there usually
is something wrong, because the behaviour is out of the ordinary, so we go in and fix it. Unless he does something like giggle, or smile when we pick him up, and then we know he's playing us... But we also wait around 5 minutes before we go in to make sure he's actually awake. Sometimes he just cries in his sleep for a bit. As for the hysterical "I'm dying" cry--like you described,
Storm--I ignore that as well. I see it as him simply upping his game, and he does still fall asleep in the end. But again, we do have a time limit for naps: 15-20 minutes, depending on the quality of his cry. We know he will not sleep if he's been crying for that long.
I do apologize for meddling, though. It's just something I've wanted to express for a long time, and since every one seems to be trying CC, not CIO, I thought I'd explain why I do what I do.
Angel--remember my "bratty" nephew? I feel so badly after learning something from my SIL that I feel obligated to exonerate him. Turns out, the poor thing has a learning disability that doesn't allow him to process a change in his plans (for example, if he plans on having ice cream after dinner, even if he wasn't promised it, he will meltdown if he can't get it). Because of this inability, he goes into a brain-freeze because he can't process this change, which in turn increases his frustration levels, and ultimately leads to this "bratty" behaviour. From what I understand, at the root of it is an inability to problem solve, something which he needs to be taught. I learned all of this when Eric told me that my SIL had taken him to a psychiatrist, who recommended a book called "The Explosive Child."ccc So I bought the ebook, and it makes total sense. It appears that living with this kid has been far harder than we thought, and most often, people believe that the parents are to blame for not disciplining the child properly (which is what OH and I did). So taking him out of Kindergarten was actually the best thing for them to do, because he needs to learn to problem solve before he ventures out into the real world on his own again.
Look at me--I'm an armchair child expert tonight.
SK--have you tried increasing your water intake? The extra water will bloat you at first, but then, because your body knows more is coming, it drains any stored water you may have. Most people lose 5 pounds really quickly because of this. I learned how well this worked when I was working on losing weight after a medication of mine made me gain tons. Sad thing is, I would give anything to be back down to that previous "over-weight weight"
Borboleta--I'm so glad that little T is better. J's got a tooth sprouting, so his bum is horribly inflamed, too.
Okay, and now I'm falling asleep. I really hope you're having/you had a good night.
