Now I am just confused. The packing slip from my ebay seller (of the Ergo with the throuth" spelling) had the return address as a boutique in Maine. So I looked up the boutique, called them, and it seems to check out..? They are closing the boutique, have a nice wrap site focused mostly on cloth diapers (also sell Maya Wraps and Ergos and a few other things), and assures me that they were purchased directly from Ergo. She said she purchased them in 2008/2009 (hasn't sold them obviously which lines up with her need to close) and will send me proof of purchase from Ergo to my email. She said her store was on the Ergo list of vendors, but since they haven't made a purchase from them for new ones in a while they aren't listed. She gave me the name of her ErgoBaby distributor that she dealt with and confirmation numbers for her orders with them as a vendor. She'll inbox me orders she made from them directly. She seemed very upset to be accused, mentioned something about how she isn't supposed to be selling them on craigslist cause Ergo doesn't let vendors discount their items (which I know is true), and said it was originally $120 in her store. It has a store label which listed $120.
I compared it to new organic ones in the store and they are identical other than the warning label having the misspelling in an extra sentence the new ones didn't include (but in the store it was chocolate and a new one and mine was dark chocolate and a few years older).. BUT the organic chocolate in the store also had the label with the 2 bold languages that looks like the fake one on page 3 (and that was from BuyBuyBaby.. which is listed on the Ergo website as a trusted vendor).. so Ergo does have some authentic carriers with labels that look like that! I don't quite know what to think.
I'm going to call Ergo tomorrow and check the serial number... just saying it was a gift so in case the vendor's story is real she isn't in trouble for selling them on ebay... just not sure what to think!