awww, TJG, i'm inclined to agree with the others, she didn't specify, therefore, she should have shut up and put up! Hope you feel better now though, and both before and after looked absoloutly lovely! I have two to make for birthdays next week and neither have been particularly forth coming in what they would like, one I have just been told sponge, scooby doo for a fourth birthday, whatever I think looks best and the other is for my boss (aaaaaarrrrrrghhhhhh!!) who just wants a Lemon Sponge parcel (my speciality!), whatever I think looks best in lime green and orange(!!!) sooooo not sure about the two colours together, think it would look better with bright pink and yellow, too, but thats what she's asked for so that's what she's getting, I'm just praying it will be ok! I too, would be very upset if no one liked one of my cakes, I think you tend to put everything into it and so it's a personal criticism on ourselves.