Kim - as long as you get the signs and trust your body then no harm in trying I guess. I must say (and this is just my opinion) that the science behind ttc a girl interests me (that is not to say that I don't think a lot of it is down to luck), so it suprises with all the scientific reasoning you have previoulsy used, that you would not ttc in months where the chinese gender predictor is not girl. This is by no means having a go at you, I am just suprised that is all. Most people are either (wait for it this is gonna be a hugely sweeping statement
) scientific in their beliefs or more (can't think of the right word, want to say airy fairy!) superstitious. You seem to combine both. Does that mean you don't completely trust the science in that even if you only had sex so that female sperm were around at ovulation, you still think it would end up a boy? Just really interested in your views Kim, it is all just very interesting!
I'm honestly not sure what to think. I do know that lots of people have said that the Chinese chart was accurate for them too. But surely others have conceived the opposite of what the chart claims they should of for whatever month they got pregnant in.
Even though I got preg with a boy (Bryson) in a month that it says was a "boy month" for me, I'm still not 100% sure if I believe in it or not.
As for the Shettles Method (the timing of BD in relation to OV) has claimed many successes and of course some failures even though more successes than failures. I bought the book by Dr. Landrum B. Shettles and there is an insert in there to cut out and fill out and mail back to himself and his business partner about your experience using the Shettles Method and if it worked for you or not. So I mean that is a form of accountability as well as the testimonies from patients of his over the years. So I dunno. I'm not sure what I think anymore. I mean if you read the book 'How to choose the sex of your baby', it explains plenty of scientific research and evidence that went into his method and made it what it is today. But of course, nothing is ever 100% guaranteed so naturally there are some failures. There is also a woman online who claims that BD exactly 12 hrs after OV will result in a girl but I'm not sure if I believe that despite her claims of testimonies. I do know that when I got pregnant with Bryson, I remember using the bathroom, after a wee, I wiped and saw a bunch of ewcm. We were on a TTC break at the time and we were basically NTNP. So I thought, it probably wont result in pregnancy but it sure wont hurt to try anyways. At the least, hubby and I had a fun time of it. Well much to my surprise I got pregnant, with Bryson. So I'm sure I OV'ed within 24 hrs of that BD.
I also know that I've seen other girls in the TTC section who could only BD 4-5 days before their expected OV day and not only got pregnant, but found out through ultrasound that they were having a girl. So I dunno.
Some docs recommend trying the Shettles Method while others say it's nothing but a guy trying to sell a book.
I probably seem very wishy washy now.
I'm honestly not sure what I believe is true and/or works. The Shettles Method seemed more scientific based so it's the one I've stuck by for the most part. I wish all of this was easier than it is.
I guess the reason I want a little girl so bad is partly because I'm dying to dress her up in all of the darling little pink frilly dresses and stuff. But another reason is that I had such a terrible upbringing and my own mother completely takes my very existence for granted, I would be in 2nd heaven to have my own little girl to dress up and spoil and love and let have all of the girlie things that she wants which I was deprived of as a child. I was pretty much forced into being a tom boy as a kid while my sister was bought barbies and dolls and such. Now I am half tom girl, half girly girl. I guess what I'm saying is that I want my own daughter to give a proper upbringing to and to have and love and cherish as I'd know how special it is to have a daughter and appreciate her every day of her life. If that makes any sense.