I don't think anyone should be critisized for having their views on smoking (be it pro OR con).
Just because someone doesn't actively smoke themselves, doesn't mean that smoking might not have affected their lives. My best friend has had ear infections plauging her all throughout her childhood, and she has asthma. She was 3 weeks overdue yet only weighed 6lbs at birth. Her Mom smoked like a chimney while pregnant. Granted, that was when people didn't know what they knew now, and smoking was allowed in patient rooms at the hospital.
So no, my Best Friend doesn't smoke, yet she has very strong opinions on it. I don't blame her. SHE didn't make the decision to smoke, it was thrust on her without her say, and SHE is dealing with the reprocussions to this day. I'm also sure that there are a TON of people who's lives have been touched by Cancer, Emphesema and all the other nasties that come along when someone chooses to smoke.
In this day of age, with all the scientific proof on what smoking does to you, I can't imagine why anyone would go back to it. Hey, I'm an "ex smoker", but I don't think that just because I used to smoke that should give my opinion more credit than someone who doesn't.
As alot of the responses on here have mentioned, when you smoke, it is never just
you that it affects. It affects your friends, family and loved ones who have to watch you slowly kill yourself. Because that's what smoking does. Find me any shred of evidence that smoking is actually GOOD for you and maybe I'll rethink my opinions.
Edit:
As with every controversial topic, if someone posts something about smoking... or drug use... or whatever that is known to not be good for you of course people are going to give their opinions. It's a forum, and that's what these threads are for. It's sensitive, so of course emotions are going to rise... especially from people who have been affected by it. Hopefully Ema knows (and I'm sure she does) that no one is "preaching" at her, just giving opinions.
Well then again, I shouldn't speak for others... so do know that I am not lecturing anyone in particular, just giving my views.