Hi Everyone,
I want to chime in on the age conversation, in part because I'd hate to think anyone got upset by what I said, and in part because I have a few things to add. ....
The first thing to mention is that this whole conversation came up because some old lady at a gym said something to make one of us feel shitty about being over 30 and having a kid. The conversation started as an affirmation of (many of) our choices to have children at a later age than women traditionally did. The point was to celebrate the benefits of being in over 30. For me, with no great partner and 10 years of grad school, it was the only possible choice. It makes me feel better to see that there are pros to this to balance the negatives:
"Forty is the New Twenty for Having Children"
https://www.psychologytoday.com/em/2043
Unfortunately, maybe we got so carried away celebrating being older moms that we weren't clear that there are also massive advantages of having kids in your 20s. Believe me, having NOT done it, I see the evidence everywhere in a sort of grass-in-greener way (after all, most of my friends did have their kids in their late 20s): easier time getting pg, maybe healthier/more low risk pg, more likely to have healthy (and younger) grandparent-type support systems, some people can have kids more on the entry-level side of their career/grad school, then aggressively pursue more promotions, etc. in your 30s (an easier plan than having an interruption when you have lots of career momentum and work responsibilities). Most people reach full brain maturity (i.e less thrill-seeking, irresponsible teenage stuff is 100% over) by early-mid 20s and can do a GREAT job - plus they might have some extra energy too
To me 28 .. 37 whats the difference? nothing really but better fertility...
I think even a very young woman can be an excellent mom. I have students (18-23 yo) who have young families and they are amazing parents - especially considering that they are struggling with limited resources of all kinds and often lack partners or really supporting parents (I teach at an inner city community college in NYC). However, I know, from following lots of students - and the stats on them - that their life opportunities are limited by too-early parenthood (at least for awhile) and they have to work three times as hard to get ahead. But they do it! (just ask my former EXCELLENT single-mom student who is not at Columbia law School)
So bottom line: Every woman can DEFINITELY be an awesome mom!!!! There are advantages and challenges to every life choice - but thats what makes life interesting!!! We are all going to make different decisions over the next 7 months, but these decisions - or our celebrations of them - aren't criticisms of OTHER choices. Its all valid!!
Now let me get off my soap box to puke and eat some crackers