Cross-posting this from the facebook group to here, because maybe this info can help any of you who may have problem-swaddlers.
--
So, FINALLY had some success sleeping tonight!
I had been reading about babies and swaddling earlier, and found an article by a momma who said she, too, thought her baby hating being swaddled but that her baby just needed a fool-proof swaddle that was escape-free. So I started looking further and found this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5K4VdZxwsu4&list=FLK5sGs-DdReQTo6PrSCR7ew&feature=mh_lolz
Decided, hey, why not? I'll try it. So when Aria woke up at 8:30pm to eat, I changed her and fed her, then realized I hadn't swaddled. Big mistake. lol. I ended up waking her up swaddling her, and she got peeved and was awake for 2 hours. I un-swaddled because she was crying, and waited. She's pretty predictable - awake for about 2 hours on the dot before falling back asleep unless it's the middle of the night (then she'll go for longer sometimes). We played, sang, etc. and then when the two hour mark neared and I could see she was drowsy, I changed, swaddled and nursed her and boom, asleep at 10:35 on the dot.
She slept until 3am.
Almost 4.5 hours! I about died when I woke up and realized this. SO HAPPY. So I quietly changed her, swaddled and fed her... but she was already intent on being wide-awake so after nursing, she began to wail and pout until I un-swaddled. Then for ten minutes she flailed on her play mat and whimpered at me, glaring as though I had broken her heart. LOL. So she's happily playing in her bouncy chair since no amount of anything would settle her, but I'm keeping my eyes on her and once she begins looking drowsy, I'm going to try again.
Now, I'm going to have to read/watch Happiest Baby on the Block like Guppy suggested. Hopefully, we'll be able to reach a better sleep compromise now! ;D
((note: it is not entirely escape proof, I found. when Aria was fussing just now about wanting to be out, when I opened the swaddle I found that she had managed to shimmy her arm up her shirt and out of the small receiving blanket constraint. so apparently, unless she's drowsy or asleep, she's still my little Houdini of swaddles... but whatever. lol))