dashka
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2011
- Messages
- 1,492
- Reaction score
- 0
dashka- sorry but id take your naturopathic docs opinion with an ENORMOUS grain of salt. she likely only sees the people it doesnt work for. i have no problem with alternative medicine (well actually i do, starting with their name even, rarely should it be used instead of traditional medicine, more as an adjunct) but when they start considering their treatments (which are rarely proven in any sort of true scientific way) more effective than evidence based tested treatments, well i have a problem with that. in this case.. so someone may not get pregnant, in the grand scheme of things, who cares. if someone dies of their cancer (ie steve jobs) when they could have been cured, well that sucks. as far as them spending extra time listening to you etc, of course they do, you pay out of pocket, they arent mandated by a government body to see x number of patients, for y amount of money in certain amounts of time etc. in addition particularly in fertility and gyn medicine the overhead is enormous, mostly related to malpractice insurance (something that a "holistic" practitioner likely doesnt carry). when i was an intern my patients LOVED me because i was willing to sit there and let them talk as long as they wanted. did that make me a good doctor, well maybe., but quite frankly the reason i could do it and my other interns couldnt was because i knew i was going into radiology and did not have to develop those sort of time management and quite frankly patient management skills.
Dr-Squid- I have to say I was upset by your reply . If your intention is to bring down others in their decision you have succeeded. I thought this thread was supposed to be about giving support no matter what your decision Anyway I thank all the other ladies who have been supporting. I am fairly new to this thread (have been on the TWW one for longer but recently found this one).
I dont think I gave you all the info (didnt think I needed to defend ) but my Naturopathic doctor actually has been specializing in fertility for the past 10 years. (Quite different from just an acupuncturist She is a DOCTOR). To get there they need to study both Western and Eastern medicine for many years. More than half her patients ARE IVF patients who see her also for acupuncture and she actually believes that Western and Eastern medicine work hand in hand when it comes to fertility. When I said in the post that she mentioned Clomid doesnt work for a lot of people and she didn't know why they give it I didnt continue what she said she said she would recommend that if I decided to go back to a fertility clinic and take meds (if Im comfortable with it) that I may have more luck with OTHER stronger ones like Gonal F (she is not against it at all as she works with IVF patients who are on all types of meds.) ...She works with supplements, diet and acupuncture but has so much expertise that she is a consulting doctor on probably the largest IVF website in Canada. So there you go.
I am a trained Registered Holistic Nutritionist so naturally I have chosen this alternative path after having tried Clomid for 3-4 cycles and was told that at the end of it my numbers were actually going down. Mind you that was 7-8 years ago so I dont know if stims and IUI might work for me now if I decide to do it perhaps with another clinic in future. Anything is possible. Everyone does what they are comfortable with at that moment.
To be honest -I would rather spend money out of pocket to have someone listen to me and my full feelings/concerns and understand what Im going through then a medical doctor who doesnt have the time (no fault of their own sometimes) to offer other options/support or look into the cause of why its happening in the first place.