• Xenforo Cloud has scheduled an upgrade to XenForo version 2.2.16. This will take place on or shortly after the following date and time: Jul 05, 2024 at 05:00 PM (PT) There shouldn't be any downtime, as it's just a maintenance release. More info here

Book Club. All Are Welcome. Reading for End of May: Dark Matter by Blake Crouch

Also:

I realize it's fiction so I'm trying to keep an open mind...but there is NO WAY an FBI agent would get away with involving his love interest in so many aspects of an investigation like that. :dohh:

Now I've moved on to a new book that really isn't much better so far. :roll: It's been a long time since I read a REALLY good book, and it's starting to annoy me. :haha:
 
I'm almost done with it! It definitely qualifies as mental junk food.

I'm up for Life of Pi! It's been sitting on my shelf begging to be read, and I haven't seen the movie.
 
OMG

A lady cut her husband's penis off and got to be a secret shopper?
Lemon, I've got a future as a secret shopper!

I didn't even think about how the stolen diamond thing wasn't even addressed. So funny. I was just so thrown by the whole weak woman thing. I loved how mad she got at Craig that he was undercover and didn't tell her and then almost immediately she was like, "I'm the best thief ever! let's have sex!" this book mad me laugh more than anything.

I'm down with Life of PI. haven't read it yet. And we know its going to be decent. LOL
 
Lemon I think you will be salvaging this group with life of pi.

WIL I did think it was julie. I hoped it was her and she had this elaborate back story as to why.

Oh that stolen diamond. Why even out it in the story. All they had to say was she went to see diamonds,would have been the very same. Maybe when she does tell him,they break up and thus really ending this book.!

Tank - secret shopper :haha:
 
Haha Whimsical, don't speak too soon, it might also be a ridiculous read. :rofl:

WIL - what book did you move onto? I'm waiting to get Nutshell from the library. It is apparently a retelling of Hamlet from the perspective of an unborn child, and I'm intrigued.

Has everyone finished Flawless? Are there any book club questions that we should answer?
 
HAHA I think we went crazy with the thoughts already. :rofl: But I'm down for questions.

I have a few:how do you all feel about how the female author portrayed Kieran? And what do you make of the fact that she is basically the only female character with any importance.
 
I honestly wasn't sure how to feel about how the author portrayed Kieran. Sometimes she seemed like a strong female character, but as soon as I'd think that she would do something so weak and pathetic. I didn't like how Kieran just did everything anyone (i.e., all the men--Craig and her brothers) told her to. She would have some great internal debate and think there was no way she was going to do what they wanted her to, and then she'd just cave. *Eye roll*

At first, I honestly didn't think about the fact that she was the only female character with any real importance. Now that you've mentioned it tank, you've got me thinking that one over. I did find it kind of strange that Julie had a pretty significant role early on in the book, yet she slowly faded into the background and we hardly heard of her the second half. But it is kind of interesting that all of the other important characters happened to be men...
 
Tank it may be possible that the author portrayed her own life through her character. not in every aspect but the emotional, needy, boy crazy, men loving way. she started with Kieran as this strong independant women that has a home and a job and is working hard to make her mark only for her to lose her spine when a man entered the scene. so basically i just got this feeling that Kieran is needy and a liar.

as WIL said, you dont realise that because at the begining Julie is there (thus me thinking she did it) and slowly its all about getting a Kieran a man.

my thoughts on this book:
this book was not what it said it would be like. there is meant to be so much more lies and secrets all to be slowly revealed to get to the killer and the end. it has nothing of that. it should be in the genre romance because thats all i took from the book. also non of her characters were fully in the book. i always felt like each had their own secrets and i did look forward to reading it and finding out only to be dissapointed.

my ending to the book:
julie masterminding the whole robbing after hearing the others do it without guns. she killing duncan because he messed up one of the robberies. duncan included in the robberies. kevin turing out to have a happy ending. Kieran revelling the truth and losing Craig, even if its for a short while but still. for a man that is always living to find the truth, one lie should be a eough to end it.
basically thats how i wanted the book to go and end.

what are your thoughts on this book? and what would your ending be to this book.
 
Yeah I also struggled with Kieran as a female lead. She was supposed to be brilliant, fierce, independent, but she never acted like it. Apart from her insight in the beginning where she realized that stealing a diamond is a bad idea, the point where she saved the girl on the train tracks, and the part where she cracked the bad guy over the head, she didn’t have much merit. She needed to be escorted everywhere. She immediately caved to the suggestion of the agents or of her brothers. She was scared to talk to journalists who were on her side. And her inner monologue was obnoxious. You could make an argument that she was at least somewhat strong until she started her relationship with Craig, and then she became useless. Which seems even worse. Being strong/independent and having a boyfriend are not mutually exclusive.

Also, yeah, this book totally wouldn’t pass the Bechdel Test. :roll: I would have loved to see at least one other strong female character as a support or a friend to Kieran, but instead we got Julie, who was dumb enough to steal a diamond and basically disappeared towards the end, Ms. Mannerly, who was a bad guy, and one of Julie’s bosses, who had like all of 3 lines.

Whimsical - I loved your ending. I’d read your book. :haha:
 
I don't know, Julie did have a good reason to steal the diamond. Her husband was a prick. :rolf: I love how she thinks getting her husband fired would be good for her in anyway. :dohh:


Whim: I also love your ending.

OK so this on is a wrap. Life of Pi is up next. Does the middle of Jan sound good what with the holidays? If we are all done sooner, thats ok too.
 
What the hell did I miss?! I'm so bad at book club :rofl:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
1,650,232
Messages
27,142,612
Members
255,697
Latest member
cnewt116
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "c48fb0faa520c8dfff8c4deab485d3d2"
<-- Admiral -->