Will reply to everyone in a bit, but just wanted to offer some advice for Pops
I understand how you feel right now, Lily was the same. We used to cry together! Having it all fresh in my mind and being out of the situation I hope you don't mind me offering my two pennys. I remember I needed babydream to sort me out lol I knew it all but when your the mum with all the emotions and the crying you sometimes can't see the woods for the trees. Firstly i would try some colief. It is lactase enzyme, and the theory is that undigested lactose that has built up in the gut throughout the day causes colicy pains. Lactase breaks it down, and it works if that's the cause of the problem. Comfort milk would have the same effect being low in lactose, so you don't need to do both.
I echo about the swaddling, use a lightweight sheet.
Consider actually doing less for her when she is crying. My theory of colic is that a it doesn't take a lot to unsettle a newborn and they eventually go into melt down at the end of the day. This could be due to pain, discomfort, or perhaps over stimulation. Even holding can exhaust them, and what do we do when they are crying? cuddle them. I'm not saying you shouldn't cuddle her, but perhaps try swaddling her and laying her down. I used to pat lily on the back like this.
Following on from the 'melt down' over stimulation theory, you might want to try white noise. Everyone laughs at me, but this is the only thing that worked with Lily. When she was in meltdown I took her to the bed room, turned off the lights, swaddled her and put the hair drier on. Your effectively creating the womb, and shutting out stimulation to help her wind down.
Try getting her into a roteine where she would be asleep during the 'colicy time' I know its so hard when she's been awake for hours and you haven't slept properly or had time for Korben. It didn't work for Lily, but a Gina F. Contented Lil Baby type roteine got my others out of the 7-10 screaming stage. Lily responded more to the baby whisperer type thing of EASY eat, activity, sleep, you. Have you read either books? Its about catching sleep cues before they become over tired and can't settle as a result.
How is she by day? does she feed well?
I'm sorry if I'm telling you to suck eggs, but I just wanted to help
I'm sure you know all this honey, just wanted to remind you or help you find a solution. x